The One Forbidden Thing
Thought for the Day.
Robert Pennock testifying in Kitzmiller v Dover.
What one expects in science is that one is going to be testing hypotheses against the natural world, and what methodological naturalism does is say we can’t cheat. We can’t just call for quick assistance to some supernatural power. It would certainly make science very easy if we could do that. We’re forced to restrain ourselves to looking for natural regularities. That’s part of what it means to be able to give evidence for something. You’ve undermined that notion of empirical evidence if you start to introduce the supernatural.
You can’t cheat. That’s all there is to it, really. You can’t cheat.