His birth certificate says he’s really female
What’s DOCTOR Rachel up to? Accusing other people of “poor sportsmanship.” Yes really.
But first there was the rallying call to the troops, excuse me I mean the “babes.”
Babes, just ignore the random transphobes. Block and let them scream into the void.
Please?
The void. He thinks that if he blocks us what we’re left with is the void. Now that’s narcissism.
Many people claim to support trans women
But often they only support us until our lives impact them in any meaningful way
In my case, people literally say they support trans women…but not in sport
There can be no ‘but’
We are either full and equal women, or not
We are.
How? Why? Based on what? He might as well say “We are either full and equal armadillos, or not”
But facts. Facts, I tell you!
And babes, facts don’t care about your feelings: medical professionals (WHO, AMA), mental health practitioners (both APA’s), and sport (IOC) all say that trans women are *real* women, are really female. Cry about it all you want. Your feelings won’t change the facts that we are.
That’s hilarious, especially coming from a philosopher. Institutions saying things=those things are FACTS. Real, true, irrefutable FACTS, unlike your stupid fluffy FEELINGS. Medical professionals, by which I mean the people who write policy statements for institutions like the WHO and the AMA, say that trans women are real women, and so that claim becomes a stone cold fact.
Derp.
Also it has to do with who matters and who doesn’t.
There’s no need for me to change *your* misguided opinion on the matter. You *don’t* matter.
Sorry. You don’t.
So we can be swept away then? Like so much rubble?
He’s so trumpy.
Everyone who *does* matter already says we’re real women, really female.
My birth certificate, passport, US green card, etc etc all say I’m really female.
Note, again, the risibly unphilosophical treatment of various official certificates as guarantees of absolute truth.
This is why I refuse to debate, live or otherwise, whether trans women are *really* women.
That debate is over.
You lost. Your feelings don’t trump our rights and basic human dignity.
Get a better hobby. Obsessing and harassing trans women is not a good hobby.
Our feelings don’t trump his rights…but apparently his feelings do trump our rights. Why is that, exactly?
The thing is, the people who oppose trans women’s full and equal rights think that the ‘facts’ are on their side.
This is why they always come back to “common sense.”
That’s not an argument, loves. It’s the last refuge of the ignorant. It means you’ve already lost, bad.
No, we don’t always come back to “common sense,” and the accusation is laughable coming from someone who claims PR releases from institutions=absolute unarguable truth.
Coming up next: the “poor sportsmanship” follies.
Isn’t that how it usually works, though? I support anyone’s right to believe nonsense like religion up to the point where it impacts me in a meaningful way.
Don’t forget the dishonesty in pretending that those doctors etc. are in unanimous agreement. But then it probably genuinely seems that way to him, given that he blocked all the disagreers.
I thought the liberal perspective on this was settled long ago, and in a way that directly goes against “Dr” (I still can’t understand how anyone gave this idjit a degree) McKinnon’s phrasing:
Your right to swing your fist ends at my face. That is, I support your right until it impacts me.
Sorry, your body will betray you. A simple x-ray would show you up. Hell, you don’t even pass in photos. If your remains are ever examined by a pathologist or physical anthropologist, they will tick the other box on the form, the one that says “M.” Not even all the hair dye, lipstick and parti-colour cycling gear in the world will help you.
I received university level biology training. Even though my career has move out of biology, I’m quite confident I can determine sex from most skeletons without issue. (The ones with some degree of ambiguity would still require a professional though)
Funny this, when their definition of woman is “feels like a woman”. That’s right, Dr. M, facts don’t care about your feelings. You feel like a woman, but facts show plainly that you are a man.
Don’t you love how consistent their arguments are (not)?
His birth certificate is a lie.