All entries by this author

Watered-down Math Books *

Feb 24th, 2003 | Filed by

Teach history by all means, but don’t de-emphasize deductive reasoning and mathematical proofs.… Read the rest



Genes, Yanks, Ethics

Feb 23rd, 2003 5:09 pm | By

When I have an odd moment, or forty five of them, I listen to archived editions of BBC Radio 4’s Start the Week. Yesterday I listened to this one from February 10, with Richard Dawkins and Janet Radcliffe Richards, as well as Robert Harvey and, finally extricated from a traffic jam, Andrew Roberts. This is a highly interesting show which touches on a number of issues we are interested in at B and W. Just for one thing, we get to hear Andrew Marr tell Richard Dawkins ‘You’re not a genetic determinist, are you,’ and Dawkins reply that he’s long been plugging that line: that the way we have evolved does not determine the way we have to be. … Read the rest



Susan Sontag is not a Postmodernist *

Feb 23rd, 2003 | Filed by

‘Even as her early criticism anticipates every academic trend from Cultural Studies to Queer Theory, she has been resolute in her resistance to everything postmodern, insisting on standards, morals and distinctions and the authority of art, experience and truth.’… Read the rest



Women Are Mediocre *

Feb 23rd, 2003 | Filed by

Oh dear, how depressing. We have fewer stars and fewer total failures; we bunch up in the middle.… Read the rest



Richard Dawkins Answers Questions *

Feb 23rd, 2003 | Filed by

On poltergeists, the tooth fairy, God-shaped holes, surprise arrivals at Pearly Gates, and 42.… Read the rest



How Many Kinds of Truth Are There? *

Feb 23rd, 2003 | Filed by

Does the CIA know it when it sees it? Do UN inspectors? Truth commissions? Journalists, spies?… Read the rest



Down With Indifference

Feb 22nd, 2003 9:09 pm | By

There’s been an interesting convergence lately of worry about passion and its absence, detachment and its dangers, or on the other hand about the intrusiveness and intolerance of passion and engagement. The two stances – passion and dispassion – have been exemplified in two thinkers: Richard Dawkins and Louis Menand.

David Bromwich took Louis Menand to task in the New Republic in January for his lack of a ruling passion or driving enthusiasm, excitement or anger, for being too easily unimpressed, too cool, too responsible and distant.

The idea of a radical break in thought is alien to Menand. The leveling of distinctions also serves as an intellectual labor-saving device. Nothing is very new; nothing, maybe, ever was; nothing matters

Read the rest


What Working Class? *

Feb 22nd, 2003 | Filed by

No fantasy is too extreme when one wants to build some luxury flats.… Read the rest



A Devil’s Chaplain Reviewed *

Feb 21st, 2003 | Filed by

Kenan Malik says ‘an obsessive concern with reason seems to me to be a virtue not a vice.’… Read the rest



Ringing Tone Provokes Suspicion *

Feb 21st, 2003 | Filed by

John Gray reviews Daniel Dennett’s Freedom Evolves, and says the obsession with freedom is a leftover from Christianity.… Read the rest



Passions Rule *

Feb 21st, 2003 | Filed by

Scholars in different fields are looking at emotion. (The list of books at the end of this article inexplicably omits Simon Blackburn’s Ruling Passions.)… Read the rest



Orwell Again *

Feb 20th, 2003 | Filed by

Hitchens, Menand, Wieseltier go to buffets over the Meaning of Orwell.… Read the rest



Analogies Don’t Work *

Feb 19th, 2003 | Filed by

Historians consider various popular analogies for the Iraq situation, and point out the bad fit.… Read the rest



CHE Links on Michigan Case *

Feb 18th, 2003 | Filed by

The Chronicle of Higher Education gives links to articles relevant to University of Michigan’s race-conscious admissions policies, a Supreme Court issue.… Read the rest



Menand on Orwell *

Feb 18th, 2003 | Filed by

Louis Menand says ‘Big Brother’ and ‘doublethink’ and ‘thought police’ are popular phrases because they prop up slippery slope arguments.… Read the rest



Miserable Apathy *

Feb 18th, 2003 | Filed by

Leon Wieseltier tears a strip off Louis Menand’s perspectivism.… Read the rest



Playing the Lone Rebel Part *

Feb 18th, 2003 | Filed by

Book on non-European contributions to science discovers what historians already know, Anthony Grafton’s review says.… Read the rest



Bioterrorism fears and censorship *

Feb 17th, 2003 | Filed by

Should sensitive biological information be withheld if it might be used by bioterrorists?… Read the rest



Rodent Studies *

Feb 17th, 2003 | Filed by

Education is about making more money so vocational training is the way to go so media studies should be fine but then what did Hodge mean by ‘Mickey Mouse’? It’s all so confusing.… Read the rest



All Hitler All the Time *

Feb 17th, 2003 | Filed by

Students at UK secondary schools are being given too much Hitler and too little of all the rest of history.… Read the rest