All entries by this author

Whither Poetry?

May 10th, 2003 9:07 pm | By

The Condition of Poetry is a perennial subject, and for good reason: there’s a lot to say. So, prompted by Barney McClelland’s trenchant essay on the woolly confusion of poetry with self-expression, I thought I would mention, and where possible link to, a few more jeremiads on the topic.

We could begin with Plato’s notorious dissing of poets in The Republic, or we could leap forward to the 16th century and compare Philip Stubbes’ Anatomy of Abuses with Philip Sidney’s derivative but eloquent Apology for Poetry. Or we could start with Peacock’s mocking Four Ages of Poetry and Shelley’s reply in the brilliant though far less amusing Defense of Poesy. Or we could start with Edmund Wilson’s … Read the rest

Clarke on History *

May 10th, 2003 | Filed by

Another attack on learning for learning’s sake, THES says.… Read the rest

Historians and Clarke *

May 10th, 2003 | Filed by

The Times Higher on the Education Secretary’s views of history and historians’ views of him.… Read the rest

Ornamentalism *

May 10th, 2003 | Filed by

The idea of education for its own sake is a bit dodgy?… Read the rest

Ars Gratia Marketing *

May 10th, 2003 | Filed by

There is a difference between content and wrapping, says the founder of the Gallery of Modern Art in Glasgow.… Read the rest

Not Opposed to Medieval Studies *

May 9th, 2003 | Filed by

But utilitarian view of education remains.… Read the rest

ALife Experiment *

May 9th, 2003 | Filed by

An ‘artificial world inside a computer’ helps explain how complex forms evolve.… Read the rest

Respect the Other Even When it’s a Virus? *

May 8th, 2003 | Filed by

A new book examines metaphors for disease and cure but leaves some others unexamined.… Read the rest

Frankencrop? *

May 8th, 2003 | Filed by

India harvests its first GM cotton, which is resistant to the bollworm but has opponents worried nonetheless.… Read the rest

Poetry and the Politics of Self-Expression

May 8th, 2003 | By Barney F. McClelland

You say, as I have often given tongue
In praise of what another’s said or sung.
‘Twere politic to do the like by these;
But was there ever a dog that praised his fleas?

William Butler Yeats

Some years ago, a mentor of mine put forth the argument: “Would you try to build a cabinet when you did not posses even the rudimentary woodworking skills or knowledge of the tools necessary to build the cabinet? Of course not, then why do so many people think they can write poetry without an iota of preparation?”

Still, many do. “Pop vocalists pose as opera singers. Important art museums exhibit installations that the cleaning staff mistakes for trash. Obscenity-riddled recitations, imposed over rhythm … Read the rest

No Facts Please, This is a Film *

May 7th, 2003 | Filed by

Cromwell transformed from theocrat to freedom fighter? Never mind, the truth doesn’t put bums on seats.… Read the rest

Who Cheesed His Virtue? *

May 6th, 2003 | Filed by

Virtuous Bill Bennett gambled away $8 million, but it’s okay because he started with church bingo.… Read the rest

Fear Is Not Rational *

May 5th, 2003 | Filed by

We’re more afraid of rare, unfamiliar dangers than more mundane and likely ones.… Read the rest

Cathartic or Inflaming? *

May 5th, 2003 | Filed by

Study says music with violent lyrics increases aggressive thoughts.… Read the rest

She Said He Said *

May 4th, 2003 | Filed by

Lynne Segal and Simon Baron-Cohen discuss whether men’s and women’s minds are really different.… Read the rest

Clothes Make the Academic

May 4th, 2003 12:30 am | By

In the very first Note and Comment of this year I linked to a heart-warming little story (the link is now dead, unfortunately) in the New York Observer about those wonderful hip folks at the Modern Language Association, which featured the profound, almost Gnostic aphorism, ‘Theorists are the snappiest dressers.’ What is it about lit crits these days, people often, often wonder; why are they so full of themselves, so grandiose, so deluded about their omniscience? It couldn’t be mere physics envy could it? Surely they’re too wised up and knowing to fall into that old trap!

Leonard Cassuto takes a look at the issue in this article in the Chronicle of Higher Education. He had to talk to … Read the rest

Is Name-Calling Free Speech? *

May 3rd, 2003 | Filed by

Organizing a demo is one thing, calling a teacher a fascist cow is another – right?… Read the rest

Violence, Mockery and Exaggeration *

May 3rd, 2003 | Filed by

Girly writing about tree-love is politically correct while boyish writing about action and adventure is not, says Thomas Newkirk.… Read the rest

Peer-review and Status Anxiety *

May 3rd, 2003 | Filed by

Scientists are more collegial and less condescending than humanists, a humanist discovers.… Read the rest

Student Evaluations *

May 2nd, 2003 | Filed by

Will Pick-a-Prof websites correct grade inflation or encourage it?… Read the rest