Do what works
Bad title.
In West Texas’ measles outbreak, families forgo conventional medicine along with vaccines
“Conventional” is not the right word there. It’s misleading at best; at worst it nudges people to avoid medicine that works.
They’re trying for the “conventional” journalistic neutrality, but it’s not neutral to apply a pejorative adjective to non-fake medicine. The issue here is doing what works to treat a dangerous disease versus doing what doesn’t work to treat a dangerous disease. It’s a life or death distinction in some cases, so major news outlets really shouldn’t blur it.
Sick families, mostly Mennonite, sit in a makeshift waiting room on the far left, and Dr. Ben Edwards is at a table on the far right. One by one, families are called over to meet with the doctor.
Edwards asks about their diet and nutritional intake but does not do bloodwork to look at levels of specific vitamins or nutrients. Based on the conversations with the parents and the child, he decides whether the patient might benefit from cod liver oil, which is high in vitamins A and D. Bottles of the product — offered at no charge — line tables in the room.
If kids are having significant trouble breathing, Edwards recommends budesonide, an inhaled steroid typically used for asthma. He does not offer vaccines.
Gaines County, where Seminole sits, has one of the state’s highest vaccine exemption rates, at nearly 18%, compared to 3% nationally. The embrace of unproven remedies shows that many members of the community are also eschewing conventional medical approaches.
The sad thing is that there is no treatment for measles – there is only prevention. If you get it, you’re stuck with it, and all you can do is try to alleviate symptoms and hope not to die.
“We need to help these kids out,” said Edwards, a family physician based an hour away in the city of Lubbock. Part of that help, he said, is by supplying kids and their families with cod liver oil and nutrition information, “like Bobby Kennedy is trying to do.”
Edwards is, of course, referring to newly confirmed Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who’s been vocal against proven medical practice. He’s encouraged vitamins and cod-liver oil over vaccination and isolation to control the outbreak.
Kennedy of course has no medical or scientific training of any kind
There’s no antiviral or cure for measles. Kids sick enough to be hospitalized are often given oxygen to help with their breathing. Studies done in other countries have suggested that vitamin A may be helpful in treating malnourished children with the disease. There’s no credible evidence to suggest cod liver oil is effective.
Though doctors here can administer vitamin A for measles, it’s typically used for severe cases in the hospital. Most people in the U.S. have normal levels of the vitamin and don’t need extra.
Too much can be toxic, said Dr. Ronald Cook, chief health officer at the Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center in Lubbock and health authority for the city. “Before I’d give mega doses of vitamin A, I would certainly get a vitamin A level” in the blood, he said.
Any messaging suggesting that vitamin A, including cod liver oil, could be an alternative to vaccination is “misleading,” said Dr. David Higgins, a pediatrician and preventive medicine specialist at the University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus. “The goal is to prevent measles from ever occurring. Every single illness, hospitalization and death [from measles] is entirely preventable with vaccines.”
But noooooooo, that’s not interesting enough for a self-involved Kennedy, he has to do a pretend-doctor act on the world stage.
The makeshift clinic and unproven treatments in Texas echo a different deadly measles outbreak in which Kennedy was involved. In 2019, as measles raged in Samoa, Kennedy, then chairman of Children’s Health Defense, connected alternative medicine doctors in the U.S. with a local self-described “natural healer,” who administered their vitamin protocols to sick children and spread fear over the Pacific Island nation’s vaccination campaign. A total of 83 people, mostly children, died in the outbreak. Kennedy has repeatedly denied any involvement in the deaths and questions whether they were caused by measles at all.
He’s a very bad man.
The organics cultists do the same: They’ve renamed any farming they don’t like “conventional farming.”
It’s just like “cis.”
Religions do it: “Apostate,” “heathen,” “gentile,” “infidel.”
Ideology leads to horseshit piled on top of horseshit.
Yes and this isn’t the wackos themselves, it’s NBC calling it “conventional” – apparently because they think it would be “unfair” or “biased” to call it real or evidence-based or science-based.
He fits right in with his boss, who does a pretend-tough guy act on the world stage.
I actually used the term ‘conventional’ farming in an exercise I did, and it was not a pejorative. It was simply acknowledging the reality that calling it ‘evidence-based’ or ‘real’ would have fouled up the experiment. My students, deep in big ag world, didn’t think it was a pejorative. They thought it was a compliment.
Sometimes pejoratives are in the eye of the beholder. In this case, I think a case can be made for conventional, because it is. It is what is done by convention throughout the midwest. Organic is the one that is different, and it is worth measuring whether it makes any difference at all, but starting out by calling the other method ‘evidence based’ ruins the entire experiment, because it is immediately biased.
And the students were shocked to find there was no difference in the beans they measured; they hear so much hype, they were sure the organic beans had to be a lot smaller than the big-ag beans, and even when they got a larger mean for the organic, it was almost impossible to convince them that they were not smaller.
Language is important when you are dealing with anything. I don’t have a problem with conventional medicine as an epithet in most cases, though I do agree that there needs to be some sort of indication that it is evidence-based and scientific, while the other is bogus.
ikn, you make many good points. Having worked on an organic farm, I was used to hearing the term “conventional” in a sense that was almost sneering. “Not one of us,” is what they meant. Now, the two terms–organic/conventional–mean nothing of substance to me, except to distinguish two methods of producing basically identical products.
I don’t see much issue with calling medicine ‘conventional medicine’, even though it really doesn’t need the added word. The problem is that ‘alternative medicine’ raises snake oil to the same level. The term makes it seem to be an alternative branch within medicine, when really it is an alternative to medicine. If a person is taking alternative medicine, they are not taking medicine.
Holms, as a doctor said to me many years ago:
“Do you know what we call “alternative medicine” that works?”
“Medicine”.
Holms, well my issue is partly that it’s not accurate and thus not informative. There’s no hippy-dippy or eccentric or colorful or non-conformist branch of medicine along with a “conventional” one. It’s like saying “conventional” engineering. It’s not a matter of convention, like wearing white gloves to church, it’s a matter of what works.
The other part is that it’s pejorative. It nudges us to think real medicine is boring and conformist and stuck in the ’50s, when none of that is relevant.
‘Dr. Ben Edwards’
Is certainly NOT a ‘small town doctor.’ A very shallow google check finds that he’s some kind of religious/political crackpot in Lubbock TX. He does have an actual MD degree…from a Texas school.
Who said he was? The article says he’s “a family physician based an hour away in the city of Lubbock.”
I just checked & found that there is no animal reservoir for measles.
So if not for the antivaxxers, measles could be made extinct.