What Did the Zimbardo Experiment Really Show? *

Jul 16th, 2004 | Filed by

That power corrupts? Or that subjects try to please the experimenter?… Read the rest



Arrogance

Jul 15th, 2004 7:13 pm | By

This is a nice bit of dovetailing, of convergence, of two minds with but a single thought, of – okay, we get the idea. Brian Leiter was talking about different examples of exactly the same kind of thing I was talking about two days ago, in ‘Close Reading’. The Little Professor noticed the parallel. Leiter’s post is really interesting; it touches on several issues I have on my sort of mental list of things to discuss sometime. It quotes Andrea Lafferty, director of something called ‘the Traditional Values Coalition’ (oh please) saying ‘There’s an arrogance in the scientific community that they know better than the average American.’ Well – uh – yeah. Because they probably do, ya know? Seeing as … Read the rest



Stupid Guy Thinks ‘Alice’ is a Girly Book *

Jul 15th, 2004 | Filed by

So he wanted revenge: ‘to rewrite it as a book boys would also enjoy.’… Read the rest



Science is Revisable *

Jul 15th, 2004 | Filed by

Stephen Hawking has changed his mind about an aspect of black holes.… Read the rest



Moral Maze Discusses Religious Hatred Law *

Jul 15th, 2004 | Filed by

Johann Hari, Steven Rose, Claire Fox and others.… Read the rest



Princes and Wheels *

Jul 15th, 2004 | Filed by

Too much speed and hard work, not enough Wiccans and stillness, don’t you agree?… Read the rest



‘Arrogance’ and Knowledge

Jul 15th, 2004 | By Brian Leiter

Andrea Lafferty, executive director of the Traditional Values Coalition, a conservative religious organization, delivers what could be the signature line for our backwards times in America:

There’s an arrogance in the scientific community that they know better than the average American.

In fact, of course, scientists do know quite a bit better than the “average American” about the matters for which their scientific expertise equips them. Those with knowledge, surprisingly, know more than those who are ignorant. Is that arrogance?

As Chris Mooney remarked, “science is not a democracy,” and in a democratic culture, that inevitably becomes a cause of resentment, as Ms. Lafferty’s comment attests. This resentment of competence was first made vivid to me when I appeared … Read the rest



Water and the West Bank *

Jul 14th, 2004 | Filed by

More science and less religious fundamentalism would be better for Israelis and Palestinians.… Read the rest



Solution to African Food Crisis is Multifaceted *

Jul 14th, 2004 | Filed by

Better science education, more research, better roads, communication.… Read the rest



Ken Livingston and Pro-Hijab *

Jul 14th, 2004 | Filed by

Yusuf al-Qaradawi got a standing ovation. Hurrah for the hijab.… Read the rest



Martha Nussbaum on Sexual Torture at Gujarat *

Jul 14th, 2004 | Filed by

Women as nation, objectification, and disgust.… Read the rest



Good Moves

Jul 14th, 2004 2:27 am | By

That’s quite amusing. I wrote the comment below before I read Julian’s new Bad Moves, which also has partly to do with Prince Charles’ medical expertise compared with that of mere, you know, medical experts.

The strict dietary regime in question is the Gerson Therapy, which eschews drugs in favour of coffee enemas and fruit juices. It has the support of well-known medical experts such as Prince Charles, interior designer Dudley Poplak and Lord Baldwin of Bewdley. Their opinions, of course, carry more weight than those of the American Cancer Society, which warns that the treatment could be dangerous.

Pure coincidence, that. And then he goes on to make an excellent point about language that helps question-begging to do … Read the rest



Close Reading

Jul 13th, 2004 11:48 pm | By

I re-read an article yesterday or Sunday that I kept wanting to do a comment on as I read it. Line by line, even word by word, in places. I wanted to comment not just on the article as a whole, but on each bit of sly rhetoric as I read and noticed it. Not a macro-comment but a micro one, not an overall comment but a close-up.

And that reminded me, in an almost nostalgic, sentimental way, of the beginning of N&C. In September or October 2002, when we were thinking about and discussing what to include on B&W, what features to add. It reminded me that we didn’t exactly think of N&C as a blog, at first, or … Read the rest



NSS Says Blunkett’s Religious Law is Dangerous *

Jul 13th, 2004 | Filed by

National Secular Society on invitation to religious fanatics to use courts to silence critics.… Read the rest



Democrats Let Themselves be Hustled *

Jul 13th, 2004 | Filed by

The herd of independent minds demands noisy religiosity from Kerry. Why?… Read the rest



At the MLA Convention *

Jul 13th, 2004 | Filed by

Essay way too long, padded, boring, but with some interesting bits.… Read the rest



Why Plagiarism Matters *

Jul 13th, 2004 | Filed by

For the same sort of reason evidence matters, logic matters, truth matters.… Read the rest



Begging the question

Jul 13th, 2004 | By

[Dudley Poplak] gave Charles a copy of the book A Time to Heal: My Triumph over Cancer – Beata Bishop’s story of how she beat malignant melanoma 23 years ago by following the strict dietary regime.
Jo Revill (Health Editor), the Observer , 27 June 2004

The strict dietary regime in question is the Gerson Therapy, which eschews drugs in favour of coffee enemas and fruit juices. It has the support of well-known medical experts such as Prince Charles, interior designer Dudley Poplak and Lord Baldwin of Bewdley. Their opinions, of course, carry more weight than those of the American Cancer Society, which warns that the treatment could be dangerous.

To say that Gerson is controversial is therefore something of … Read the rest



Occidentalism Reviewed *

Jul 12th, 2004 | Filed by

Rebellion against the West is a Western export.… Read the rest



A Quick Twirl

Jul 11th, 2004 11:40 pm | By

Another miscellany, because there is an ever-growing backlog of items I want to point out and perhaps say a few words about – and I only have six hands you know. Be reasonable. I’m going as fast as I can, here, but I can’t do everything. And besides I have this mosquito bite or spider bite or moth bite or whatever the hell kind of bite it is just right at the bend of my elbow, on top where it gets maximal chafing from my sweatshirt, and it itches, dammit! It’s been itching for days and days and days and days. Normally bites stop itching after a few days, am I right? But this one just keeps on going, like … Read the rest