People and their experiences
Forced teaming and Vatican rags:
In the eyes of many LGBTQ Catholics
I have to stop you right there. Seven words in and you’re lying already. There are no LGBTQ Catholics. There can’t be. It’s not a thing. LGB is sexual orientation, Q means nothing, T is genner idenniny which is 1. bullshit and 2. incompatible with LG.
NBC of course found someone to explain with all due ponderous verbiageification what the new pope means to him her them us you insert chosen pronoun somewhere.
Jason Steidl Jack, a gay Catholic and an assistant teaching professor of religious studies at St. Joseph’s University, New York, described his reaction to the election of Pope Leo, the first-ever American to lead the Holy See, as “cautiously optimistic.”
“I do see him continuing Pope Francis’ legacy, especially of dialogue and synodality,” Steidl Jack said, describing synodality as “this idea of journeying together” and “listening to one another.” However, he said the new pope’s election “doesn’t assuage all of the fears that I have as an LGBTQ Catholic.”
“The church’s teaching, even under Pope Francis, remains incredibly homophobic, and the church goes on inventing new ways of being transphobic as it really avoids learning about trans people and their experiences,” he said, adding, however, that the new pontiff seems “open to dialogue and inclusion” given his remarks on Thursday.
Learning what “about trans people and their experiences”? That people continue to know the differences between women and men? That not everyone is eager or willing to change the definitions of “woman” and “man” such that they mean their own opposites? That most people still understand why women don’t want men taking over everything that used to belong to women?

Just what exactly is it that I can learn that will convince me that trans bullshit isn’t bullshit?
Somehow just “listening” to trans people is always assumed to be sufficient to effect epistemic alchemy, stripping away all my base, terfy transphobia to reveal a glittering, intersectional rainbow of inclooooosion. Or something.
“Epistemic alchemy” should be a band name.
Nullius in Verba: that’s a grave miscalculation on their part. “Learning about trans people” is how we make new terfs.
Add alchemy to most things and you end up with a decent band name. “Mad Dog Alchemy”, for instance
Piglet #3 : “Learning about trans people” is how we make new terfs.”
Ah. Cue the old meme where Julia Serrano, Jacob Tobia, Grace Lavery, Andrea Long Chu and Alok Vaid-Menon reveal their *REAL* reasons for identifying as women:
https://x.com/SFWAustralia/status/1637852428593770496