When witches are tranzfobik

When confusions collide:

A practising witch claims she was thrown off a druid training course over accusations by a member of the UK Pagan Federation that she was “transphobic” in a row about women’s rights.

When even the Druids believe it you know it’s gone mainstream.

Angela Howard said she became involved with paganism and joined the British Druid Order (BDO) in 2020 to find “spiritual healing” after being sexually assaulted.

Somebody needs to set up a British Terf Order.

However, Howard said the solace she sought in druidry and paganism was shattered when she was banned in April from continuing her training because of her support of the exclusion of trans women — males who identify as female — from single-sex spaces for women.

The dispute began, she said, three days after the landmark Supreme Court judgment that ruled the definition of a woman under equality laws related to biological sex, rather than “certificated gender” acquired by trans people.

She said the Pagan Federation put up a post on its official Facebook page entitled: “Statement of Support for Trans People from the Pagan Federation”.

According to Howard, 48, in contradiction of the Supreme Court ruling, it asserted that trans women should be regarded to be exactly the same as biological females and that this position was “not up for debate”.

Well not exactly in contradiction of the ruling, because the ruling doesn’t tell people how we should or should not “regard” things. The ruling leaves us free to “regard” men as women if we want to. The law is about actions, not thoughts. Laws about thoughts are extremely hard to police, so legislatures and courts generally avoid them.

Howard said she responded to this statement by commenting that there were situations in which women needed single-sex spaces, such as changing rooms, women’s refuges and prisons. She illustrated the point by citing her own experience of being sexually assaulted by a trans person, a man who identified as a woman, and being unable to access a rape crisis service because it was “mixed-sex”.

And so they punished her because of course they did.

Four days later, the British Druid Order also banned her from their Facebook page when she criticised an article posted there that described the Supreme Court ruling as a “victory for bigotry”, she said, adding that her response included only one line of criticism, an expression of sympathy for trans women in prison. She also asked the article’s author whether he had read the judgment.

However, she said she was expelled from the site by its administrators after a member of the Pagan Federation support team claimed she had been “more unequivocally transphobic” in her comments.

Of course. This is how you win points in The Great Global Who Is Most Transphilic contest. You keep your eyes and ears open for the tiniest deviation from Transphilic Law and then you pounce before someone else does. Ding ding ding! You get to move forward ten steps.

In a written complaint to the BDO this week, Howard pointed out that women and girls were the “largest and most consistently oppressed group worldwide”, adding: “Even here in the UK, I cannot safely wear a witch’s hat in public without receiving threatening or fearful looks.”

Well…I hate to spoil the fun, but you also can’t wear a chicken on your head in public without receiving threatening or fearful looks. Funny clothes are going to get funny looks, because people expect the expected. That is after all the whole point of wearing a witch’s hat or a chicken when out in public.

6 Responses to “When witches are tranzfobik”

Leave a Comment

Subscribe without commenting