Author: Ophelia Benson

  • God tortures only those who ask for it

    William C Chittick PhD is a professor of religious studies at SUNY Stony Brook. He wants us to understand “the Islamic notion of mercy.” He tells a story to illustrate it.

    Another account tells us that the Prophet had stopped to rest at a bedouin camp, where a woman with an infant was baking bread over an open fire. The child slipped away and approached the fire, and the mother quickly pulled him back. She turned to the Prophet and said, “Do you not say that God is ‘the most merciful of the merciful’?” He replied that he did. She said, “No mother would throw her child into the fire.” For a moment the Prophet turned away and wept. Then he said that God puts into hellfire only those who refuse to go anywhere else.

    Chittick seems to think that that illustrates genuine mercy. I think it illustrates the pathetic and disgusting tininess of the theocratic mind. “God” is all about mercy; for example, he puts people into hellfire for eternity only if they don’t jump when Mohammed says jump.

    That’s not mercy, you fucking fool.

  • Joseph Hoffmann on giving up on spirituality

    Rule number one: it has to be easy. Rule two: it has to be available. Rule three: it has to be blendable.

  • Jack of Kent on Pilger on Assange

    Pilger cheerfully accuses others of criminal activity while briskly dismissing such accusations against Assange.

  • William Chittick on the Islamic notion of mercy

    “The Prophet said that God puts into hellfire only those who refuse to go anywhere else.” How merciful.

  • A flawed museum show on “Muslim Heritage”

    “1001 Inventions,” the literature says, “is a nonreligious and non-political project.” But it actually is a little religious and even more political.

  • Natasha Fatah on the cost of Sweden’s kindness

    Malmö was supposed to be a symbol of Sweden’s multiculturalism. But it is in danger of turning into an Islamist ghetto.
  • After the storm

    You should see Puget Sound right now.

    We get a very interesting phenomenon here in the aftermath of a particular kind of winter storm, locally called a “pineapple express,” in which warm temperatures combine with heavy rain to cause massive river-flooding. The phenomenon is that Puget Sound is two colors instead of one. For a distance of maybe a quarter of a mile from shore, the water is pale green, and beyond that it is the usual grey.

    I remember staring at this oddity in befuddlement the first time I ever spotted it, and then suddenly realizing what it is. Silt, of course.

    It’s incredibly impressive. That is one hell of a lot of mud, that can turn all that water a different color. Do admit.

    It’s been changing all morning, as the clouds thicken or thin. One minute it’s a subtle effect, and the next it stands out as if lit by a spotlight. From where I’m sitting I can see a grain ship at anchor (the grain terminal is just at the bottom of the hill) in the middle of all the pale green – the line between the green and the grey is well to the west of the ship.

  • Sudan’s “judiciary” launches “investigation”

    Oh, you saw that? Well we’ll look into it right away. We’re shocked, shocked.

  • Life with sadistic laughing bastards

    In Sudan, watching men whip a terrified woman is a source of amusement.

  • The “Islamophobia” myth

    American Jews are far more likely to be the victims of religious hate crime than members of any other group.

  • Off with his head!

    They’re kidding, right? This is a joke? It has to be a joke – right? They can’t be serious?

    A doctor has been arrested for insulting the Prophet Mohammed in Pakistan…

    Naushad Valiyani was detained on Friday following a complaint by a medical representative who visited the doctor in the city of Hyderabad.

    “The arrest was made after the complainant told the police that Valiyani threw his business card, which had his full name, Muhammad Faizan, in a dustbin during a visit to his clinic,” regional police chief Mushtaq Shah told AFP.

    “Faizan accused Valiyani of committing blasphemy and asked police to register a case against the doctor.”

    And the police obliged.

    So………no phone books can be thrown out in Pakistan? No newspapers or magazines? They must all contain myriad instances of the name “Mohammed,” so if it’s blasphemy to dispose of any bit of paper on which the name “Mohammed” appears, then that would seem to be the rule, yes?

    Shah said the issue had been resolved after Valiyani, a member of Pakistan’s Ismaili community, an offshoot of Shiite Islam, apologised but local religious leaders intervened and pressed for action.

    “Valiyani had assured Faizan that he did not mean to insult the Prophet Mohammed by throwing the visiting card in the dustbin,” Shah said.

    So why didn’t Shah tell the “local religious leaders” to fuck off? Why didn’t the “local religious leaders” tell each other that they were a disgrace to the species? Why – oh never mind.

  • Pakistan: doctor arrested for “blasphemy”

    A sales rep named Mohammed Faizan gave the doctor a business card; the doctor put it in the wastebasket. Blasphemy!

  • Sweden bomber lived in Luton

    He had a BSc in sports therapy from the University of Bedfordshire and a hobby of trying to explode people.

  • Court rules against Helen Ukpabio and the Liberty Gospel Church

    Today a Federal High Court in Calabar in Cross River State, presided over by Justice P.J. Nneke, dismissed the application by Helen Ukpabio and some members of the Liberty Gospel Church seeking to enforce their fundamental rights against Akwa Ibom state government, the Commissioner of Police of Cross River state, Assistant Inspector General of Police, Leo Igwe, Sam Ituama, Gary Foxcroft and others as respondents for daring to organize a workshop which they perceived to be critical of their activities. They asked the respondents to pay them 200 billion naira ($.1.3 million dollars) in damages.

    The court wondered why Helen and her church members attacked some of the respondents and still came to court to enforce their fundamental rights for the mere reason that the victims of the attack dared report the matter to the police. The court dismissed the application and awarded costs of 20,000 naira(184 dollars) against Helen and her church members. Helen Ukpabio, her church members and her lawyers were not in court today for the ruling.

    It should be recalled that last year over 150 thugs from Helen Ukpabio’s Liberty Gospel Church invaded the venue of a workshop on Witchcraft and Child Rights in Calabar. They attacked and beat up the organizers of the program. The police intervened and arrested some of them; in their statement they said they were sent by Helen Ukpabio to disrupt the event. Shortly after the arrest, Helen and her church members went to court to enforce their fundamental rights. Early this year, Helen’s lawyers did not appear in court on two occasions and the court had to strike out the case. But a month later, the leader of her legal team Victor Ukutt went to court and re-listed the case.

    “This is a landmark judgment and a victory of the rule of law over the law of the jungle. I am greatly delighted that the court has sent a strong message to Helen and her church members who have continued to use their connections to evade justice and to undermine the cause of reason, enlightenment and human rights.”

  • Nigeria: court rules against Helen Ukpabio

    Last year over 150 thugs from Ukpabio’s Liberty Gospel Church invaded a workshop on Witchcraft and Child Rights and attacked the organizers.

  • Ghana: woman burned to death for being a “witch”

    Ama Hemmah was allegedly tortured into confessing she was a witch, doused in kerosene and set on fire.

  • Expensive communication

    Stephen Law offers us a video of the Permanent Secretary for Government Communications telling a bunch of people that communications are goods things and that he is goods at doings them. I watched a minute or two, which was enough to confirm me in my surmise that I didn’t want to watch more than that. Stephen explains why.

    He has little to say, surely? Strip out the “successful behavioural outcomes”, “partnership”, “stakeholder”, “co-creation”, “we’re on a journey” jargon and rhetoric, and his message boils down to:

    • The public used to be seen by Government as passive recipients of information, not as customers to engage with, which they now are, ‘cos of the internet, twitter, etc. Citizens can now provide feedback on services.

    • There should be more effective working together between government departments.

    • Government needs to apply psychological research if Government wants to affect behaviour, not just make ads saying: “stop smoking”, “eat less fat”, “do more exercise”, “get a job”, etc.

    Now, surely, all of this is pretty trite and obvious, not cutting edge insight? Won’t everyone in the audience already know this? Most of us know it, surely. It’s platitudinous.

    Yes but you need a highly-paid expert to say it so that…well so that he can earn his high pay. What else would you have him do? Teach philosophy?! Come now.

    3. Much of what Tee says seems to serve primarily as a device for reminding us of how successful he has been. The talk is in large part a puff for himself and his career.

    4. Is Tee himself a good communicator? I found this presentation dull, uninformative, and I suspect it’s unlikely to motivate his audience to do anything different. The one concrete bit of advice he gives them is: think of how your next communication might be tweeted.

    As I say, Tee earns over £160,000 per year of taxpayer’s money (equivalent to, say, the combined salaries of three university professors). Maybe he’s very good at managing. But I’d say he’s a rather poor communicator and, on the basis of this performance, a bit light on ideas.

    You might think that, but I couldn’t possibly comment.

  • Abandoning FGM in the Afar Region of Ethiopia

    The strategy is to gain the support of a core group, which decides to abandon the practice then helps mobilize enough people to facilitate a tipping point.

  • Simon Blackburn replies to Sam Harris

    It’s one thing to know the world, it’s another to care.