Then scrapes bottom of barrel to find enough people in favour to justify claim.… Read the rest
All entries by this author
The Archbishop’s Lecture in full
Feb 8th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonDr Williams has been reading Tariq Ramadan.… Read the rest
Bishop Fumes at Reception of Sharia Idea
Feb 8th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia Benson‘I believe he was standing up for the different faith communities.’ We know; that’s the problem.… Read the rest
Peter Tatchell Urges Mercy to Qaradawi
Feb 8th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonHe wants to come to UK for medical treatment; let him. Perhaps a gay Israeli Jew will save him.… Read the rest
Sharia Okay As Long as it’s Liberal Sharia
Feb 8th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia Benson‘The fundamental purpose of sharia is to achieve justice.’ Is it?… Read the rest
Bravo is it?
Feb 8th, 2008 9:40 am | By Ophelia BensonBravo, Rowan, says Jeevan Vasagar breezily. Well, he’s a man; easy for him to say.
In Tanzania, for example, Muslim family law applies to Muslim citizens. When it comes to questions of divorce, custody and inheritance, Muslim families settle their disputes at courts unique to their communities.
Yes we know, and Muslim family law treats women and men unequally. That is the problem.
There’s an interesting clash here – a classic liberal dilemma. Do you promote the rights of a minority community or do you worry more about the rights of Muslim women, who may get treated less generously under sharia than under secular law?
It’s not really a dilemma once you think about it hard enough. Just for one … Read the rest
Forced or arranged
Feb 7th, 2008 1:39 pm | By Ophelia BensonThere’s that report on Honour-based violence in the UK. It starts off by discussing forced marriage – and right away I got snagged by an obstacle.
According to most definitions, a marriage becomes forced if any coercion, physical or psychological, [is] used against either spouses [sic] in order to force them to consent. A forced marriage is not the same as an arranged marriage which occurs with the full consent of both parties.
No the obstacle isn’t how desperately the report needs copy-editing; it’s full of mistakes and typos, but that’s not the obstacle. The obstacle is that item about the full consent. What is full consent? Under what conditions is it possible? How prevalent are such conditions? All … Read the rest
An important pillar of our social identity hem hem
Feb 7th, 2008 1:04 pm | By Ophelia BensonI transcribed something the Archbishop said just before the ‘bit of a danger’ remark.
… Read the restA lot of what’s written suggests that the ideal situation is one in which there is one law and only one law for everybody. Now, that principle, that there’s one law for everybody, is an important pillar of our social identity as a Western liberal democracy, but I think it’s a misunderstanding to suppose that that means people don’t have other affiliations, other loyalties, which shape and dictate how they behave in society – and that the law needs to take some account of that. An approach to law which simply said ‘There’s one law for everybody and that’s all there is to be said’ –
A bit of a danger
Feb 7th, 2008 12:17 pm | By Ophelia BensonI got a record number of email messages alerting me to the Archbishop’s fun new ideas on the subject of law and religion, which seems to hint that they may not be as sound as they are exciting.
Dr Rowan Williams told Radio 4’s World at One that the UK has to “face up to the fact” that some of its citizens do not relate to the British legal system.
Quite so. UK murderers, rapists, extortionists, batterers – they do not relate to the British legal system. Good idea to face up to that fact, if one hasn’t already. But is it a good idea to actually adopt ‘certain aspects’ of murderers’, rapists’, extortionists’, batterers’ law? I would say no.… Read the rest
Crimes of the Community
Feb 7th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonThe full report. [pdf]… Read the rest
Listen Again to the Archbishop
Feb 7th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonPeople have other loyalties; the law needs to take some account of that. Oh yeah?… Read the rest
MySpace ‘Atheist and Agnostic’ Page Restored
Feb 7th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonGroup’s founder said MySpace has shut down the 35,000-member webpage twice since 2004 founding. … Read the rest
Saudi: Woman Arrested for Sitting With Man
Feb 7th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonUS woman jailed by Saudi religious police for sitting with a male colleague at a Starbucks in Riyadh.… Read the rest
Reactions to Archbishop’s Exciting Ideas
Feb 7th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonBBC talks to Gordon Brown’s spokesman and to Nick Clegg. They say one law is adequate.… Read the rest
Archbish Says Sharia is Unavoidable in UK
Feb 7th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonThinks it’s ‘a bit of a danger’ to say there is one law for everyone.… Read the rest
Haggard Leaves Early
Feb 7th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia Benson‘Spiritual advisers’ say he shouldn’t return to the ministry. Not straight enough yet.… Read the rest
What would Becket Do?
Feb 7th, 2008 | By R Joseph HoffmannRowan Williams is not a bad man. He is certainly not a stupid man. He is an Oxford scholar and one in a long train of academic bishops who are as comfortable at High Table in Balliol or in lecture halls on the High Street as they are intoning the tropes of Elizabethan liturgy in clouds of incense at Canterbury.
Why then has the good bishop failed to be fitted for a new mitre, since the one he is wearing has clearly cut off circulation to his brain?
In an address from Lambeth Palace on February 7th, Williams delivered a lecture entitled “Islam in English Law: Civil and Religious Law in England.” I cannot imagine that anybody confronted with the … Read the rest
Not one speech can be taken on trust
Feb 6th, 2008 5:14 pm | By Ophelia BensonRichard Evans’s Lying About Hitler: History, Holocaust, and the David Irving Trial is a fascinating book. And it’s highly relevant to the question of whether or not it’s a good idea to debate Irving. Holocaust Denial on Trial has Evans’s report for the trial; see for instance his General Conclusion.
… Read the restIrving is a particularly dangerous spokesperson for Holocaust denial because over the years he has consistently portrayed himself as a scrupulous historian with an unrivalled knowledge of the archival sources and an unerring eye for forgeries and falsifications. As we saw in Part I, he has repeatedly claimed that he is waging a ‘campaign for real history’ against legend and myth, truth against falsehood. ‘Real history’, he says, is
Another Afghan Journalist Under Threat
Feb 6th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonNasim Fekrat reports on Basir Ahang; no one has heard from him for a month.… Read the rest
Vote on Hijab Ban in Turkey
Feb 6th, 2008 | Filed by Ophelia BensonTwo thirds of Turkish women wear hijab – so the ability to refrain will erode.… Read the rest