All entries by this author

Surprise at Muslim Scholars’ Rejection of FGM *

Dec 1st, 2006 | Filed by

‘I thought Islam told us to do so,’ said Samar.… Read the rest



Simon Blackburn on Harry Frankfurt on Truth *

Dec 1st, 2006 | Filed by

Utility sits uneasily with truth; we need an explanation of how the virtue of truth can stand opposed to pragmatism.… Read the rest



Redundant

Dec 1st, 2006 2:15 am | By

Nigel Warburton interviews Richard Norman and asks why he rejects the idea that God exists. Norman gives a good clear succinct answer that would cut through a lot of the disputes that keep turning up like clumps of dust under beds.

I believe that the onus is on those who believe in the existence of a god to provide reasons for that belief. (This is a point which the philosopher Antony Flew has well made.) I can’t prove that there is no god, but in the absence of good reasons for believing that a god exists, I live my life without belief in a god. In particular, the success of scientific explanations of the natural world makes religious explanations redundant.

Read the rest


Well, yes and no

Dec 1st, 2006 2:14 am | By

Ken Livingstone offered a Millian version of multiculturalism in the Indy yesterday.

Multiculturalism versus its opponents is simply one manifestation of the age-long struggle between liberty and its opponents. It is not about personal differences of opinion but between the values of an open and a closed society.

Yes but which side is for the values of the open society and which is for those of the closed? Things don’t necessarily line up the way Livingstone claims.

The foundations of liberalism and multiculturalism were outlined with great clarity in what is justifiably the most famous political essay in British history, John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty…Every individual who exists is unique, and wishes to pursue their life in a different way.

Read the rest


More on atheist appreciation of religious art

Dec 1st, 2006 2:13 am | By

Nigel Warburton has a very interesting guest post by Richard Norman on the ‘Whether Atheists Can Appreciate Religious Art’ topos. Norman talks about Piero della Francesca’s ‘The Resurrection,’ which his comment caused me to look at again. It’s a terrifically interesting painting; I already thought so, but the discussion intensifies that thought (as such discussions tend to do, which is one huge reason art criticism and literary criticism are not footling wastes of time); it also made me think about why.

Some of what Norman said:

The assumption here is that the truth presented by a religious work of art must itself be a religious truth. That is what I want to question. Of course Piero’s painting is a depiction

Read the rest


Nigel Warburton Interviews Richard Norman *

Nov 30th, 2006 | Filed by

‘The success of scientific explanations of the natural world makes religious explanations redundant.’… Read the rest



Oral History Bumps into Regulation *

Nov 30th, 2006 | Filed by

With colleges wary of potential lawsuits, oral historians find their work caught up in regulatory reviews.… Read the rest



Michael Walzer on the Utilitarianism of Extremity *

Nov 30th, 2006 | Filed by

When our deepest values are radically at risk, the constraints lose their grip.… Read the rest



Why Arendt Matters *

Nov 30th, 2006 | Filed by

Arendt blurred categories; a philosopher who offered notes on the very latest world affairs.… Read the rest



Ronald Dworkin Reviews Peter Kramer’s Freud *

Nov 30th, 2006 | Filed by

‘Freudian analysis is not science; it is fashion, totally dependent on public acclaim.’… Read the rest



How to Train a Computer to Think Like a Person *

Nov 30th, 2006 | Filed by

Intelligence Augmentation uses human beings as part of computer programs.… Read the rest



Scott McLemee on the Yale Book of Quotations *

Nov 30th, 2006 | Filed by

Billie Holliday and Bob Dylan, worth the space, but ‘Plop plop fizz fizz’?… Read the rest



Nigel Warburton Interviews Stephen Law *

Nov 30th, 2006 | Filed by

Consider the relationship between sentimentality and Christmas.… Read the rest



Are we rational self-interested choosers?

Nov 30th, 2006 | By H E Baber

The fact is that most of the people engaged in political violence today—from the Basque country to the Philippines—are not fighting for individual rights, nor for that matter are they fighting to establish an Islamist caliphate. Most are fighting for a national homeland for the ethnic nation to which they belong. For most human beings other than deracinated north Atlantic elites, the question of the unit of government is more important than the form of government, which can be settled later, after a stateless nation has obtained its own state. And as the hostility towards Israel of democratically elected governments in Palestine, Iraq and Lebanon shows, democracy can express, even inflame, pre-existing national hatreds and rivalries; it is not a

Read the rest


Ken Livingstone on Multiculturalism *

Nov 29th, 2006 | Filed by

‘What is prohibited is one group or person imposing their will on others.’ Tell that to al Qaradawi.… Read the rest



Oxfam Report on Education in Afghanistan *

Nov 29th, 2006 | Filed by

Seven million Afghan children are out of school while five million children attend school.… Read the rest



Oxfam Says Most Afghan Children Not in School *

Nov 29th, 2006 | Filed by

Girls are particularly losing out: 1 in 5 girls in primary, 1 in 20 in secondary school.… Read the rest



Misery of Women in Afghanistan *

Nov 29th, 2006 | Filed by

‘We were very happy. Rawa came and talked about how they could help us. But that has stopped now.’… Read the rest



Taliban Tear Teacher to Pieces; He Taught Girls *

Nov 29th, 2006 | Filed by

He was part-disembowelled and then torn apart with his arms and legs tied to motorbikes.… Read the rest



Sharia Law Spreading in the UK *

Nov 29th, 2006 | Filed by

‘Some lawyers welcomed the advance of what has become known as “legal pluralism”.’… Read the rest