Every other

What a damn fool question.

If someone’s a sexual predator, they’re a sexual predator, but assuming that all trans people are sexual predators – like we wouldn’t do that for any other protected minority so why is it okay to do it to trans people?

Well, of course, it’s not ok to assume that all trans people are sexual predators, but then that’s a hyperbolic question. I don’t suppose that many people do assume that all trans people are sexual predators, but it’s not unreasonable to keep in mind that claiming to be trans is a very good dodge for someone who is in fact a sexual predator. There’s a difference.

This is one of the chokepoints of the ideology. Claiming to be trans is a good way to hide being a sexual predator, and that fact in turn is a good reason to be at least cautious about taking all claims of all trans-identifying people as automatically and always forthright and true.

To sum up: trans is not like “every other protected minority”.

Comments

7 responses to “Every other”

  1. iknklast Avatar

    And missing the point that it is impossible to tell which ones are sexual predators until it’s too late.

    It’s just like women are taught to avoid unknown men in risky situations. Most of the ones we meet aren’t dangerous, but we don’t know which ones.

  2. Papito Avatar

    The easiest way to tell which strange men aren’t dangerous is that they’re the ones who start yelling at you if you look at them funny. Or was that the other way around?

    And, sure, not all trans people are sex pests. But it’s not like the two things are unrelated, or all the troons in jails wouldn’t be sex pests. So if the man you see in women’s bathroom is wearing a skirt, it’s _more_ likely he’s a sex pest.

  3. Mike Haubrich Avatar
    Mike Haubrich

    The only place that the “Shrodinger’s Rapist” doesn’t apply is when we are decidedly looking away to prevent being called bigoted for not wanting men in dresses in women’s private spaces.

  4. Holms Avatar

    This whole avenue of argument is a red herring they want to introduce, as it plays into the victimhood they must maintain while also distracting from the real issue reasoning: trans women are excluded from women’s spaces because trans women are male and women’s spaces are for the female sex. Male people are excluded not because all male people are sex offenders, but because sex offences are linked to the male population generally.

    Any given male person intruding when women are e.g. changing clothes would reduce a woman’s feeling of safety, even if that guy was perfectly ordinary and inoffensive. Hence male people are excluded without any need for such an assumption.

  5. Arcadia Avatar

    “ If someone’s a sexual predator, they’re a sexual predator, but assuming that all [male adults ignoring female boundaries and the law] are sexual predators – like we wouldn’t do that for any other protected minority so why is it okay to do it to [male adults ignoring female boundaries and the law]?”

    Hmm, a mystery I guess.

    Additional mystery as to why we exclude known perfectly lovely and non threatening adult males (think of the nicest, loveliest, least threatening fella you know here, but for my purposes, I’ll just say Michael J Fox) if the only matter at hand is posing a danger or alarming women?

  6. Bjarte Foshaug Avatar
    Bjarte Foshaug

    Exactly, if you don’t want to be seen as a sexual predator, forcing yourself into women’s toilets, showers, changing rooms etc. while male is not an option that’s available to you. If you still insist on doing so, you have already shown that women’s boundaries don’t matter to you and that whatever they want is not going to stop you from going after what you want, thus marking yourself as a greater potential threat. Again, I happen to know for a fact that many of the people currently hell-bent on abolishing female only spaces used to know this back in the days when so many of them kept eagerly citing the “Schrödinger’s Rapist” argument.

    And this is where obligatory lumping together of effeminate gays (roughly corresponding to what used to be known as “transsexuals”) and autogynephiles (roughly corresponding to what used to be known as “transvestites” or “erotic cross-dressers”) into the single category of “trans”, as if both groups were somehow subsets of the same group in any meaningful sense, is so damaging. I strongly suspect that the vast majority in the former category just want to pass under the radar as much as possible in order to get on with their lives. I would be surprised if many of them were vehemently opposed to, say, using gender-neutral toilets as opposed to the ones reserved for biological females*. To the autogynephiles, on the other hand, the whole point of forcing themselves into female-only spaces (thus making them no longer female-only) in the first place is to live out their sick, shameful fetishes at women’s expense.

    * As many others have pointed out, this is where the whole “safety” objection breaks down. If this were simply a matter of avoiding male violence, there is no reason why only (formerly) female only spaces should be acceptable to these people.

  7. Mike Haubrich Avatar
    Mike Haubrich

    Now, if you see an article about someone arrested or convicted of rape, there are multiple comments along the lines of “you’ll notice that he wasn’t a trans women or a cross dresser.”

    No, what I notice is the word “he.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *