How the horrors of our past

Not the right guy to be saying this kind of thing.

The Transatlantic slave trade is long gone. There are other slave trades though.

Comments

19 responses to “How the horrors of our past”

  1. chigau Avatar

    The entirety of the USA prison system is slavery.

  2. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    For more, see Worse than Slavery: Parchman Farm and the Ordeal of Jim Crow Justice by David Oshinsky.

  3. Athel Cornish-Bowden Avatar
    Athel Cornish-Bowden

    One of my very distant ancestors operated a slave market in Barbados, so I have nothing to be proud of, and there may well be others that I don’t know about. However, a much more recent ancestor, my paternal greatgrandfather, was one of the good guys, and devoted the later part of his career in the Royal Navy to suppression of the slave trade. One could say that he was just following the orders he received from the Admiralty, but it’s clear from the letters he sent to his relatives he believed fervently in what he was doing. In the first period he was active in the region of the River Congo, but that came to an end when the ending of the Civil War in the USA made it less necessary, and he moved to East Africa, in the vicinity of Zanzibar, where Islamic slave trading was very active.

    Just about every powerful nation in history practised slavery at some point. In the Americas the USA was not alone: Portugal (Brazil), the Netherlands (Surinam), Spain (Colombia and others), the UK (Jamaica and others), and France (Haiti, Guadeloupe, Martinique) were enthusiastic slavers. The countries that didn’t go much in for slavery, such as Canada and Chile, had economic systems that wouldn’t have gained much from being slave-based.

  4. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    And slavery goes way back in history.

  5. iknklast Avatar

    Just about every powerful nation in history practised slavery at some point

    And I imagine some that weren’t powerful did, too, though I’m no expert.

  6. Ian Hargreaves Avatar
    Ian Hargreaves

    “Not the right guy to be saying this kind of thing.”

    Burnham, or Khan?

    Also – at least the UK actually abolished slavery, unlike the US.

  7. twiliter Avatar

    Also – at least the UK actually abolished slavery, unlike the US.

    Not true. Look up the 13th Amendment to the Constitution, ratified Dec. 6, 1865. Not sure why you’re so anti-US there, Ian, but a little research goes a long way.

  8. Ian Hargreaves Avatar
    Ian Hargreaves

    “Look up the 13th Amendment …a little research goes a long way.”

    Oh dear. How embarrassing for you.

    How about YOU look up the 13th Amendment. I have.

    I’m going to quote from the FIRST SENTENCE of the Wikipedia entry. Not the whole sentence – I only need to quote one word.

    “except”.

    It’s one of my favourite quiz questions: when did the US abolish slavery? Answer: it hasn’t, yet. The so-called abolition shamefully contains a very specific and very consequential exception – unlike the abolition as enacted in the UK, or pretty much anywhere else that unlike the US *actually* abolished slavery.

    “Not sure why you’re so anti-US there”

    Not sure why you’re so anti-easily-verifiable-facts there.

  9. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    That’s exactly what the Oshinsky book I recommended is about. Because of that clause, the South was able to hang on to slavery for another century, except that as the title says, it was worse than slavery, because there was no financial incentive to keep the prisoners/slaves alive. No need to buy slaves when you’ve got Parchman Farm.

  10. twiliter Avatar

    Fair enough, Ian, thanks for the lesson. I guess people have no business celebrating Juneteenth then?

    Still, why the disdain?

  11. twiliter Avatar

    Maybe I should learn about prison labor laws in the UK while I’m at it.

  12. Ian Hargreaves Avatar
    Ian Hargreaves

    What a bizarre suggestion. People can celebrate whatever baby steps towards civilization they please. I don’t suggest gay people don’t have pride parades, but then they’re not pretending the Stonewall riots were the end of the fight for gay rights, rather than perhaps the start.

    And if you’re asking why the disdain for a country that (checks notes) *hasn’t abolished slavery* … are you for real?

    You’re the one who turned up with a patronising suggestion I do some research, and pointed me to examine a document that proved me right. No flicker of self-awareness there.

  13. twiliter Avatar

    So if forced prison labor is considered slavery, and it is, then how is the UK superior? Today I mean. Wages?

    (research is good! sorry to sound patronizing)

  14. twiliter Avatar

    And I question my self awareness constantly, so thats fine, a bit ad hom but fine. I simply don’t understand why the *what I perceive as* excessive hostility. I mean some hostility is fine, there are many things wrong here in the US, but saying the US hasn’t abolished slavery despite the ‘exception’ that was exploited, and still is being exploited seems largely semantic. Historically yes, but I don’t see any fundamental difference today; forced labor is forced labor, both here and there.

    It’s not as if the 13th doesn’t exist and has no meaningful content.

  15. Omar Avatar

    The behavioural psychologist B.F. Skinner demonstrated that he could ‘teach’ animals to do all sorts of tricks by rewarding closer and closer approximations of the desired behaviour with something the animal desired: food when deliberately kept hungry, water when deliberately kept thirsty, and so on and et cetera.

    On the basis of that, I maintain that if I have control over any of your essentials of life: in order air, water, food, homeostasis (warmth etc) and freedom of movement, then I can blackmail you into doing anything I want you to do. Just ask any current or ex jailbird.

    I have worked as an outsider with such slaves. They and their prison guards had come to a working agreement; neither side would give any trouble to the other, provided that it operated both ways.

  16. twiliter Avatar

    Well, I’m not thrilled about how slow the US is w/r/t evolving towards increased civility either, but I don’t hate it (nor do I hate the UK either, Bertrand Russell wrote keenly about nationalism). The Constitution is an extraordinary framework despite whatever flaws that back then needed (and still need) ironing out.

  17. Jim Baerg Avatar

    Does anyone know of a culture that *never* practised slavery?

    Even some hunter/gatherer societies took slaves from neighboring tribes. Eg: Great Slave Lake has that name because the tribes living near it were raided for slaves by other tribes.

    Late medieval Europe seems to have dropped slavery before other societies, though still having serfdom makes that a rather modest improvement. The Europeans then took up slavery again when they colonized other lands.

  18. twiliter Avatar

    Even a few animal species exhibit dulosis.

  19. quixote Avatar

    It never ceases to amaze me how quickly people veer off into talking about other groups when female slavery is mentioned. Yes, there’s current slavery, a lot of current slavery we could be worrying about if it’s so abhorrent. If I remember the numbers right from a world stats report I read, about 80% of current slavery is female.

    Plus, female slavery just about invariably includes constant rape. There’s plenty of psychological research showing that adding a sexual component to misery more effectively destroys mind and self than any other method. (Did anyone think the military psychologists at Abu Ghraib were stupid? Have you heard of any subsequent resistance leaders who survived that torture and went on to do great things? Aside from a few women?) Slavery that includes sexual slavery is right at the lowest level of hell.

    It’s really necessary and good that people are pointing out, hey, slavery is not all in the past. It’s also really important to focus at least sometimes on the largest –and most abused– group victimized.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *