Team Let’s Strangle Women

This guy is an academic, a lecturer at Queen Mary University in London.

https://twitter.com/ObhishekSaha/status/2117526625235410961

What he means is that women who object to men strangling women are prudes, and women who cheer men strangling women are down women. He offered this “chart” in the context of a discussion of men strangling women as a “kink”. Not people strangling each other, mind you, but specifically men strangling women. He thinks women who object to men strangling women are prudes. And he says so on social media. And he’s an academic.

Comments

26 responses to “Team Let’s Strangle Women”

  1. Colin Day Avatar

    I’m offended by his use of a Venn (Euler) diagram to justify this.

  2. twiliter Avatar

    Wow, a worthless poster that explains nothing. Except maybe his own misogyny. QED the idiots with PhD’s nowadays.

  3. twiliter Avatar

    Maybe he’s better at math than mansplaining. Let’s hope so.

  4. Ian Hargreaves Avatar
    Ian Hargreaves

    The title of this post is… misguided. That chart is not about what men want, prefer, ask women to do, or do to women. In fact, it’s rather the opposite of that.

    What he means is that women who object to men strangling women are prudes

    He’s not talking about “women who object to men strangling women”. He’s talking about women who object to women actively wanting to be strangled.

    women who cheer men strangling women are down women.

    Women who cheer men doing what women ask them to do, because it makes those women happy, are “down” women.

    Not people strangling each other, mind you, but specifically men strangling women

    If you don’t think there’s a subset of men who get off on being strangled, you’ve presumably never heard of Stephen Milligan. Or Michael Hutchence. Or David Carradine.

    Now, personally, I don’t get it. Not from either side. But then, I don’t “get” being homosexual either. I don’t “get” a whole bunch of other people’s sexual preferences. But – and this is the big one – it’s none of my fucking business what gets other people off.

    Anyone who has read Nancy Friday’s “My Secret Garden”, or who has had something more than a pretty low number of heterosexual women as sexual partner, would not regard as controversial the assertion that a significant minority of women get off on things that it would be overly simplistic to describe as “being strangled”. Been there, been asked to do that.

    It’s also in the realm of observable fact that their preferences, which definitely exist and to which they are entitled, make some other women very vocally and viscerally angry to the point of incoherent (see the title of this post). He’s talking – possibly mansplaining, but that’s a different conversation – about what some *women* want, seek out, and aren’t (in my experience) shy about *actively asking for* unprompted, and about how that makes other women who aren’t into it feel when they find out it happens.

    You could take issue with labelling the women who loudly don’t like it as “prudes”, but I’d defend it like this:

    Women who will seek this out are a subset of larger group of sex-positive and relatively promiscuous women, and the larger group they’re a subset of are happy to have their own preferences and mind their business about anyone else’s. Even a large proportion of what this bloke calls “tendersexuals” that overlap with the “down” crowd are happy to get on with their own preferences and live and let live. You could draw a loop round the whole lot of those people and perhaps label them sex-positive libertarians.

    This guy needed a word to describe people who are NOT into BDSM, NOT largely sex-positive and promiscuous, and have only a passing overlap with even mildly sexually active women, BUT DO feel it’s their business to loudly object to the sexual preference of others. The opposite of a tolerant, reasonable person.

    You may object to the use of the word “prude”. It definitely has negative connotations and I suspect that may be why he picked it, he clearly wants to upset such women further. But if not that word to describe people whose identity is concerned with policing the sexual preferences of other consenting adults – what would you call them?

    Sexual moralists? Puritans? Slut-shamers? Sexual gate-keepers? Or that most disgusting of possible slurs…. conservatives?

    Strangling, as a subset of BDSM, is definitely one of the sexual practices that has come more into the public eye as a result of the regrettable rise of easily available internet porn. It’s a distressing fact that young people will be exposed to the sight of this sort of thing before they’re ready to understand what they’re seeing, the importance of consent and the complete unacceptability of non-consensual violence. And of course there’s the issue that there’s a subset of young men who will pressure partners who are NOT into it, because they’ve not been taught about or don’t care about consent. But that’s not a new or different problem, and it’s nothing to do with what this bloke is talking about.

    But just as there’ll always be a subset of men who are enraged that women don’t want sex (with them, or the way they think it should be done), there’ll also always be a subset of women who are enraged that women DO want sex (with men, and in a way they disapprove of). “Prudes” seems to me a reasonably accurate term for them.

  5. Ian Hargreaves Avatar
    Ian Hargreaves

    Aside: it’s a minor, mildly interesting linguistic peculiarity I’ve observed that, in the US, a woman who actively wants sex is “down” for it, whereas in the UK she is “up” for it. Is there some deep meaning to be gleaned from this? I doubt it.

    Also, this is something that is applied exclusively to women, because there’s a harmful stereotype of men that they are all, ALWAYS, down/up for it.

  6. iknklast Avatar

    people who are NOT into BDSM, NOT largely sex-positive and promiscuous, and have only a passing overlap with even mildly sexually active women,

    I am not sure what point you are making here, but are you sure it’s accurate? I know a lot of women who are NOT into BDSM, NOT largely promiscuous, but have a huge overlap with mildly (and in many cases, largely) sexually active women.

    Women who are sexually active do not necessarily get into BDSM. Those who object to it are not ‘prudes’; many of them are sexually active themselves, and are horrified about women dying from a sexual act. We speak up, and frequently, about suicide. Why should this be different?

    The problem isn’t that women want to be strangled, so much. The problem is that they are not actually asking to be strangled to death. It appears to me (from the outside; I admit I have none of the ‘special knowledge’ of the insider) that BDSM requires trust in one’s partner…trust that they will not go too far, trust that they will stop before they hurt the partner. So, no, the women are not asking for death, they are asking for a thrill that only works if their partner is trustworthy, knows when to stop, and recognizes that they are stronger than their partner…though I have little doubt that someone who is not stronger could manage to strangle someone when their hands are around someone’s neck.

    there’ll also always be a subset of women who are enraged that women DO want sex (with men, and in a way they disapprove of). “Prudes” seems to me a reasonably accurate term for them.

    This is just ignorant. I suspect there is some overlap between women who disapprove of BDSM and those who are enraged that women want sex with men (though I’m not sure the last is that huge a population; I have known a few lesbians and radical feminists who fit that description, but for the most part, women who are not interested in men shrug off the idea of women who are interested in sex with men). That overlap might not even be enough to show on a pie chart or Venn diagram. Many of us who are bothered by this practice are sexually active women engaging in long-term and/or short-term relationships with…you guessed it…men.

    We regulate many activities with lower risk of harm – smoking, drinking, drugs all come to mind – but when the practice is sexual, we are told ‘hands off, it’s choice and you’re just kink-shaming’. No, I’m kill shaming. That’s a HUGE difference.

  7. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    So anyway. Thinking and saying that men should not strangle women has nothing to do with “prudery”. The problem is not doing it for sex thrills, the problem is doing it at all. Strangling bad. Strangling make dead.

  8. maddog1129 Avatar

    Sex is for love and fun.

    Strangling is neither.

    Strangling as “kink” is on a level with playing Russian roulette.

  9. Freemage Avatar

    Ian: What you are missing is that this particular kink is dichotomous in what it says about the two people involved.

    It says the woman is willing to risk her own life in order to get off.

    It says the man is willing to risk the woman’s life in order to get off.

    These two things are not the same.

  10. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Funny how there are no men who want to be strangled, isn’t it.

  11. Bjarte Foshaug Avatar
    Bjarte Foshaug

    And once again – as in the case of women who supposedly want to sell their bodies – demanding that all other women volunteer to live in a world in which the kinds of male attitudes about women that have to exist for a man to treat women’s bodies as a rentable commodity, or even put their lives in danger to satisfy his sick, disgusting inclinations, are normalized just so that you can choose to cater to them, is in itself a hostile request.

  12. Ian Hargreaves Avatar
    Ian Hargreaves

    Funny how there are no men who want to be strangled, isn’t it.

    I hate to repeat myself but…

    If you don’t think there’s a subset of men who get off on being strangled, you’ve presumably never heard of Stephen Milligan. Or Michael Hutchence. Or David Carradine. And that’s just the m most famous ones who died.

  13. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    You also hate to use blockquotes. Please use them anyway; I’m tired of having to insert them for you.

  14. Ian Hargreaves Avatar
    Ian Hargreaves

    Freemage – you missed a crucial word out.

    It says the man is willing to risk the woman’s life in order to get HER off.

    Assuming, as in good faith you must, that what’s at issue is consensual, because of its not, it’s just assault or murder. Suggesting it *can’t* be consensual is just wilfully ignoring reality.

  15. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    No. It’s not in good faith to assume that men who are eager to strangle women are doing it for altruistic reasons.

  16. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    What you’re ignoring here is that strangling is dangerous. It’s not just “kink”; it’s not just a fun sexy variation on missionary position; it’s extremely dangerous. The danger is mostly to women, for obvious reasons. It’s not altruistic for men to do it to women, and it is dangerous for men to do it to women, so they should not do it, even if requested. Of course in general people can do whatever kink they like, but strangling is not in general, strangling is highly specific.

  17. Karen the Chemist Avatar
    Karen the Chemist

    One thing I’ve been wondering about: The ones who want to be strangled, do they want the strangling/restriction on breathing, or the effects of oxygen deprivation on the brain? The light-headedness or whatever. Wouldn’t an inhalant provide those effects? Of course, those can be dangerous, too.

    For some or partial restriction on breathing, there’s corsets. There are women who wear them (see steampunk). Way back in the day, some men wore corsets. I don’t know if they make corsets for men these days. (TeslaCon, a steampunk convention, is coming up soon. I can check vendors there. I recall seeing some at a TeslaCon in the past, modeled at a fashion show.)

  18. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    I didn’t quite get to the part I object to most.

    But just as there’ll always be a subset of men who are enraged that women don’t want sex (with them, or the way they think it should be done), there’ll also always be a subset of women who are enraged that women DO want sex (with men, and in a way they disapprove of). “Prudes” seems to me a reasonably accurate term for them.

    That’s so insulting. I’m not enraged that women DO want sex with men, and I didn’t say anything to suggest I am. And I’m not talking about “a way” of having sex with men, nor am I talking about disapproval of women who DO want sex with men. I’m talking about strangling. That I do disapprove of, yes, just as I disapprove of stabbing, shooting, punching, hitting with a rock, poisoning, and so on. It’s not “prudish” to disapprove of men strangling women. I disapprove of men strangling women because they lose their temper and because sex.

  19. twiliter Avatar

    A pie chart showing how many women enjoy being strangled would be more illustrative and proportionate. I’m sure it’s a vanishingly small sliver. As it stands, it’s manospherish rubbish he likely gleaned from the more depraved corners of the internet. Whatever “research” he did reflects that. It’s a load of made up shit.

  20. Ian Hargreaves Avatar
    Ian Hargreaves

    It’s not in good faith to assume that men who are eager to strangle women are doing it for altruistic reasons.

    Then you are ignoring, wilfully, what’s being talked about in the article you linked to. It’s specifically about consensual behaviour, because as I said, if it’s not consensual, it’s just assault/murder. You may or may not approve of that consensual behaviour, but you can’t just announce that it’s not.

    What you’re ignoring here is that strangling is dangerous.

    You’re damn right, and I’m not ignoring that at all. A lot of sexual behaviours are dangerous. Gay men knew unprotected sex with men was dangerous in the 80s, and we know how that turned out. Taking drugs is dangerous. Driving fast is dangerous.

    When I first learned (as a result, I think, of the death of Stephen Milligan) that oxygen deprivation intensifies the experience of orgasm, my first thought was “hmm…. interesting….”, followed pretty much immediately by “yeah, nah”. And that manifested in two ongoing behaviours: (a) never asking for it and (b) never doing it when asked.

    The danger is mostly to women, for obvious reasons

    Absolutely not. Again, you’re conflating three things:

    (1) participation in a dangerous consensual activity

    (2) violent assault risking manslaughter

    (3) deliberate murder

    I don’t have any major problem eliding (2) and (3), but again – that’s not what the article you chose to link to is talking about. It just isn’t.

    it is dangerous for men to do it to women, so they should not do it, even if requested

    In my life I’ve chosen never to do it, specifically for that reason. But if consenting adults want to get up to something in the privacy of their bedroom, I’m firmly on the page that, pretty much regardless of how dangerous it is, it’s none of my business. Or yours. It becomes our business when it strays into the realm of crime.

    Boxing is, unarguably, dangerous. But if a woman wants to box a man, she’s free to, if he’ll agree to box her. Would you disapprove of that? And either way – what is the extent to which you want to insert your preferences into the private behaviour of consenting adults?

    @Karen The Chemist:

    The ones who want to be strangled, do they want the strangling/restriction on breathing, or the effects of oxygen deprivation on the brain?

    My experience suggests about 50/50. As to why they don’t use chemicals to simulate it, I’m *guessing* that it’s because it’s free, easily available, and a superior experience to the chemical simulation.

    OB again:

    I’m not enraged that women DO want sex with men, and I didn’t say anything to suggest I am.

    And I didn’t say YOU were a prude as defined in the article.

    I’m not talking about “a way” of having sex with men”.

    But the article you linked to is. Hence the confusion.

    I’m talking about strangling.

    And specifically you’re defining that word to exclusively refer to an assault… which isn’t what the article is about.

    It’s not “prudish” to disapprove of men strangling women

    If the the strangling is consensual, is ASKED FOR, it is.

    Here’s the thing – I’ve been asked to do it, by more than one person. And I’ve declined. And I’ve been explicitly called prudish for it, and it’s cost me experiences. And I’m fine with that. But I’ll also own it – yeah, to that extent, I am a prude. I have limits. I’m prudish about a bunch of stuff I’ve been invited to do, some of it considerably more distasteful to me than a bit of light strangling. Sign me up. I just don’t judge other people for wanting it, just because it’s not for me.

  21. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Dammit, I asked you to follow the local convention and use blockquotes. Now I have to go through this very long comment and replace “” with blockquotes to make it readable. Again: please use blockquotes.

  22. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Now that your comment is readable – Cambridge Dictionary:

    Prudish is an adjective that describes someone who is excessively or ridiculously proper, modest, or formal in their speech, conduct, or dress, and who is easily shocked or offended—especially by matters relating to sex or nudity.

    It’s not excessively or ridiculously proper, modest, or formal to say that men should not strangle women.

  23. twiliter Avatar

    How to:

    Key in a lesser-than angle bracket, followed by a forward slash, followed by the word ‘blockquote,’ followed by a greater-than angle bracket. Type in, or better yet copy and paste the quote. Then again, key in another lesser-than angle bracket, followed by the word ‘blockquote’ (without the forward slash), followed by another greater-than angle bracket. Rebut, rinse, repeat.

    A convenient little tutorial (for whomsoever may need it) provided by your friendly neighborhood pedant. :)

  24. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    It’s wrong though; the forward slash is at the end, not the beginning.

    Anyway I assume an adult knows how to google.

  25. twiliter Avatar

    I’ve made that mistake more than once, but you know that. :D

  26. Arcadia Avatar

    Ian, I think what you’re missing is that there is no safe way to strangle someone. A young woman (just a teenager) died in Australia in recent months due to (reportedly) consensual, requested strangulation by her partner, himself also just a teenager, who reportedly loved her. I doubt those two had any idea about “how to do safe strangulation”, which is actually impossible, even though I’m sure many a BDSM devotee will tell me I’m wrong and that they’ve done it heaps and are totally fine.

    Women can die, even days later due to damage sustained during strangulation, or get permanent brain damage. Previous non fatal strangulation is also the single largest indicator of a domestic violence perpetrator who will go on to murder his partner, or ex partner. Attempts at strangulation are also common, with young women in particular stating in surveys that many of their male partners want to do it to them during sex, offering, or trying without even asking first.

    There’s also the We Can’t Consent To This campaign, which deals with the matter that many, many of these sexual strangulations leading to death are not at all consensual, but rather, a bullshit claim the murderer makes in court after he’s killed a woman.

    This has almost nothing to do with prudery, sex, or even consent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *