Another first

Worse and worse.

Ten minutes before oral arguments for the birthright citizenship case at the Supreme Court began on Wednesday, a hush came over the courtroom. President Trump walked in and came face to face with justices whom he has tried to bully and intimidate.

Mr. Trump became the first sitting president to attend oral arguments at the court, watching from the courtroom’s public gallery as the justices across the ideological spectrum questioned his efforts to strictly limit birthright citizenship.

The first. Not the good kind of first; the other kind. Blatant intimidation move. Nice little court ya got here.

He watched as the arguments began and delved quickly into a history lesson about the 19th century debate surrounding the 14th Amendment.

That will have been gibberish to him. The what now? What century? What debate? What amendment? What mean? Is there a comic book version?

Trump, who has appointed three justices to the Supreme Court, has often talked about the justices not as independent checks on his power appointed for their expertise but as loyalists who should support his agenda. Last month, he suggested that Justices Neil M. Gorsuch and Amy Coney Barrett, whom he nominated during his first term, were “an embarrassment to their families” because they sided with the majority against him.

That’s what he knows. Mobster loyalty. The history of enslavement and the 14th Amendment, not so much.

Many people outside the court expressed strong opposition to the president’s presence.

“I think it’s basically kind of a strong-arming tactic, wanting to be there, intimidate them with his presence,” said Michelle McKeithen. “And, kind of a statement of: ‘Make a decision while I’m here, looking you dead in your eye — and don’t make the wrong decision.’”

Damn right that’s what it is.

Comments

2 responses to “Another first”

  1. Papito Avatar

    Trump can glower all he wants to, it’s not going to work. His argument is too wacky and ahistorical to win. All the same issues and questions have been hashed out extensively, on the record, in the past. You’d have to go all the way back to Wong Kim Ark, and say the Court decided that case wrongly, or even before, to to Lynch v Clarke, before the 14th Amendment was even passed. It’s a position that is so far outside American legal tradition that I expect a 9-0 ruling.

    For lagniappe, the lawyer arguing the case on behalf of the ACLU is a citizen thanks to birthright citizenship – her Taiwanese parents were on student visas when she was born.

    And because Trump is dumb and wrong about just about everything, no the US is not the only country with a tradition of jus soli. Almost every other country in the Americas does, for starters.

  2. Mostly Cloudy Avatar
    Mostly Cloudy

    “Is there a comic book version?”

    If only life *were* like a comic book. Then Wonder Woman /Spider-Man /the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles would seize Trump, give a speech telling him how horrible his behaviour is, and then drag him off to jail.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *