All very hush-hush

Stoney Creek Camels Rugby Club is on Facebook.

Their most recent post is June 23, announcing the game the next day.

There is one comment on the post, but it’s “not visible” – which I surmise means it has been hidden, which I further surmise means it was a question about the man who played in the match, and perhaps about why the video of the match was made private yesterday.

It’s not the crime, it’s the coverup.

Comments

10 responses to “All very hush-hush”

  1. Naif Avatar

    The incident in question was in the preceding weekend’s match versus Fergus.

  2. Naif Avatar

    Note also that if the photo is of the player in question, the green and white are the colours of the Fergus Highlanders, that double blue is Stoney Creek.

  3. tigger_the_wing Avatar
    tigger_the_wing

    Naif, if the bloke did injure three women using illegal tackles, in the manner he’s been accused of doing, then those injured players would be on the Stoney Creek team not his own.

  4. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Ah, Fergus; thank you for the correction.

  5. NightCrow Avatar

    From Fergus Highland’s Facebook page in March this year:

    Fergus Highland RFC

    31 March

    ·Highland recognizes and supports #transvisibilityday We see you. We celebrate you. We believe in #rugbyforall and would like to remind our community of our support for the @rugbycanada Trans Inclusion Policy. ️‍⚧️

    The page is archived at https://archive.fo/5GMJl

  6. NightCrow Avatar

    The post by Fergus Highland stating their commitment to the Rugby Canada trans inclusion policy is here.

  7. NightCrow Avatar

    Rugby Canada’s Trans Inclusion Policy, which was finalised on January 1, 2019, states, inter alia:

    7. At both recreational and competitive levels, an individual may participate in their expressed and identified gender category. An individual will, at the time of registration, identity their gender category for the playing season and may request a change in gender category at anytime during a playing season and such request will be considered by Rugby Canada.

    8. Individuals are not required to disclose their trans identity or history to Rugby Canada or any of Rugby Canada’s representatives (e.g., coaches, staff, Directors, officials, etc.). …

    10. Rugby Canada will not disclose to outside parties any documentation or information about an individual’s

    gender identity and expression. A trans individual’s privacy and confidentiality will be respected.

    In 2020 World Rugby recommended that for safety reasons transwomen should no longer be permitted to play women’s contact rugby. Rugby Canada announced that it would not be falling into line. A body called Canadian Women & Sport applauded the decision, stating: “This ban violates the human rights of transgender and gender diverse people, forcing them out of sport and denying them the benefits it brings.”

    I think this may explain why there have been no official statements about this episode, and why, indeed, there’s a strong whiff of cover-up: it is very embarrassing, both for the club and the sport’s national governing body.

  8. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    And thanks for all the informative links NightCrow.

  9. maddog1129 Avatar

    If you want to maintain secrecy about paperwork denying/lying about what everyone can see with their own eyes, then you should not have any “Day/Week/Month/Year/In-your-face-24/7/365 of Visibility.”. Either you want people to know, or you don’t. Either you’re “out and proud” or you’re not. You can’t have it both ways. If you’re making a big spectacle of yourself, it’s no longer private. You’ve waived your “privacy.”

    This ban violates the human rights of transgender and gender diverse people, forcing them out of sport and denying them the benefits it brings.

    Oh, you big fat liars! Nobody is “forcing” the men who say they’re women “out of sport.” They can continue to participate in sport in the division set aside for their SEX, i.e., the MEN’S division. Nobody has a human right to lie about their human sex. Lies, and the lying liars who tell them.