At the morgue

Pro Publica reports:

At the morgue, the babies were brought in with their diapers and blankets and with their hospital ID bracelets still wrapped around their tiny ankles. The pathologists’ findings were like those you would typically see in ailing adults, not newborns — the kind of bleeding seen during strokes or brain tissue loss similar to what happens when radiation is administered to treat cancer.

Their autopsies, which took place over the last several years, all came to the same conclusion: The deaths were caused, in whole or in part, by a rare but potentially fatal condition known as vitamin K deficiency bleeding.

In almost every case, the babies’ deaths could have been prevented with a long-standard vitamin K shot. But across the country, families — first in smatterings, now in droves — are declining the single, inexpensive injection given at birth to newborns to help their blood clot.

Many of them are doing so out of a well-meaning but ill-informed abundance of caution. In the hopes of safeguarding their newborns from what they see as unnecessary medical intervention, they have shunned fundamental and scientifically sound pharmaceutical intervention. The trend is also fueled by a contradictory pairing: families’ fierce desire to protect their babies and a cascade of false information infused into their social media algorithms.

Although it is not a vaccine, the vitamin K shot has been swept up in the same post-pandemic tide that has led to a drop in key childhood vaccines, including for measles and whooping cough.

Post-pandemic plus contemporary with Robert Kennedy’s loud confident quackery.

Two weeks ago, at a House subcommittee hearing, Rep. Kim Schrier, D-Wash., pressed Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to reassure parents that the vitamin K shot is safe. He refused and pushed back.

“I’ve never said, literally never said, anything about it,” Kennedy said.

“That’s exactly the point,” responded Schrier, who is a doctor. “You don’t say anything about it, but the doubt you’ve created about all of medicine and science is causing parents to make dangerous decisions.”

Babies who don’t get the vitamin K shot, research shows, are 81 times more likely than those who do to develop late vitamin K deficiency bleeding, where in many cases oxygen can’t reach their brains and blood pools around their skulls. Perhaps most alarming is that, according to the CDC, 1 in every 5 babies with vitamin K deficiency bleeding will die.

But Kennedy refuses to use his influence to warn parents. Nice guy.

Comments

9 responses to “At the morgue”

  1. iknklast Avatar

    When (more likely if) the madness ends, he needs to be charged with murder.

  2. Omar Avatar

    “Babies who don’t get the vitamin K shot, research shows, are 81 times more likely than those who do to develop late vitamin K deficiency bleeding, where in many cases oxygen can’t reach their brains and blood pools around their skulls. Perhaps most alarming is that, according to the CDC, 1 in every 5 babies with vitamin K deficiency bleeding will die.”

    That is a statement resulting from reason and empiricism, not irrational quackery, nor religious faith, nor patterns in tea leaves, nor from some gypsy gazing into a glass ball.

    Based only on what I have seen in the media over the years, I do not think that either Kennedy’s father RFK, nor his uncle JFK would have gone down some intellectual rabbit hole like this.

    Could be down to something RFK Jr ate or drank.

  3. Piglet Avatar

    In a lot of countries, the neonatal vitamin K is administered as drops, by the parents. The drops aren’t as good as the injections, but I do wonder if offering it to American parents as an option would be worth doing for the sake of fewer brain bleeds.

  4. Mostly Cloudy Avatar
    Mostly Cloudy

    Omar:

    “Based only on what I have seen in the media over the years, I do not think that either Kennedy’s father RFK, nor his uncle JFK would have gone down some intellectual rabbit hole like this.

    Could be down to something RFK Jr ate or drank.”

    RFK Jr.’s grandfather (the awful Joseph P. Kennedy Sr.) arranged for his luckless daughter Rosemary Kennedy to get a lobotomy because JPK thought it would “cure” Rosemary’s mental disabilities.

    https://www.irishcentral.com/roots/history/rosemary-kennedy-jfk-sister

    Looks like the advocacy of hideously harmful quackery skipped a generation.

  5. Omar Avatar

    Mostly Cloudy:

    Noted.

  6. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    It wasn’t even so much that the senior Kennedys thought it would cure her as it was that they wanted to make her more docile and inconspicuous. As she matured she became more “difficult” and they didn’t like that so off to the surgeon with her.

  7. Mike Haubrich Avatar
    Mike Haubrich

    Are hospitals and ObGyns forbidden from sharing information on the Vitamin K shot? These parents are in the hospital for delivery, but they don’t trust the advice of the staff, the nurses, doulas, midwifes, pediatrician, obstetrician? I don’t get why all of a sudden they need the Secretary of the HHS to make a statement.

  8. Mostly Cloudy Avatar
    Mostly Cloudy

    Ophelia: Yes, I should have mentioned that the senior Kennedys saw poor Rosemary’s “difficult” behaviour as a “PR problem” and wanted to change her to make her more pliable. The lobotomy was intended to alter her actions.

  9. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    And it altered them all right. Just horrific.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *