Ruined WHOSE life?
Ross Greer questioned the “reliability” of Sandie Peggie as he complained that the employment tribunal involving her had “ruined” the life of Dr Beth Upton. The Scottish Greens co-leader also doubled down on his refusal to call trans double rapist Isla Bryson a man,
hitting out at[rebuking] this line of questioning by the BBC.
So the Scottish Greens co-leader thinks Sandie Peggie is the one who messed up someone’s life, and that it wasn’t at all “Beth” Upton who messed up Sandie Peggie’s life. Women must always comply when men tell them to, even (or especially) when the men in question are pretending to be women and forcing themselves on women in the rooms where they change their clothes. Men who say they are women are both heroic and fragile, while women who say men are not women are wicked and terrifyingly strong and violent.
Sometimes it seems as if men don’t even try to understand.
Greer went on:
“And I don’t think it has been good for anybody involved in that situation. But I do keep coming back to the fact that Beth Upton, the doctor here, was dragged through this whole process. Horrible accusations were made of her. Her private life was invaded constantly. Her face was plastered all over the place. And in the end, the conclusion was, she had absolutely no case to answer.
“She had done nothing wrong. She was a doctor who was just trying to care for her patients. And for no other reason than being trans, her life has basically been ruined by this situation. So, let’s imagine that for no other reason than being Jewish someone had been dragged through that same situation. I think we would all acknowledge how outrageously utterly unacceptable that was.”
Lying or stupid or both?
Yes he had done something wrong, no he was not just trying to care for his patients. He was also using a women’s changing room despite being a man, and he did everything he could to wreck Sandie Peggie’s career as a nurse after she objected to his presence in the women’s changing room. That is in fact something wrong.
The comparison to being Jewish is wildly offensive.
I think men like this should have to wear a label, so that women know to stay well away from them.
From the article:
Both. No way he doesn’t know enough to know what Isla Bryson is. Mr Greer’s a god damned liar.
We’re supposed to believe this, and also believe that he doesn’t know enough to be able to say that maybe Isla Bryson didn’t belong in a women’s prison.
The facility Nurse Peggie and Mister Doctor Upton work at apparently has two separate sets of changing rooms. One set is for doctors, and one set is for nurses. Each set is separated by sex. Many people have wondered why Mister Doctor Upton was not invading the changing room set aside for female DOCTORS. Why was he being allowed to invade the changing room set aside for female NURSES? Leaving all the trans nonsense aside, he was not supposed to be where he went for that completely different reason. I have never seen a trans activist even attempt to answer this question – all of them ignore the question and either disappear or go off on some derailing attempt. Does anybody know why this was not brought up (as far as I can find out) at the hearings? Has there ever been an answer for this from any of the pro-trans people?
@Southwest88 #2
I don’t think many T/Allies have ever even acknowledged the question, or that the question has even been posed to them by others.
I would hazard a guess as to the reason, however. There are typically many fewer female doctors than female nurses: more victims. There’s also that class thing so often in Britain. Women doctors are more likely to be class equals of Dr Upton; the nurses are treated as subordinate, both by role and by class. They’ve been trained to ‘know their place,” and to be properly deferential to doctors, and to not rock the boat. So it’s pretty simple, I expect: more women to spy on and intimidate, and a lesser chance that his victims would do anything to stop him.