Throwing some random mud

A guy called Howard Bryant (apparently a columnist at the Guardian, despite the fact that he can’t write) has lofty disdain for women who don’t want men replacing them.

Invoking a wounded innocence that their desire for sports to be simple, just like they used to be, conservatives for a decade and a half have dreaded the word “politics”. Now they cannot get enough.

Wut? The first clause of the first sentence doesn’t even make sense.

Never mind; he moves on to Sophie Cunningham.

Largely anonymous politically or otherwise during her eight-year career, Cunningham – she of the viral finger-point which has been adopted as a symbol of the white animosity toward the WNBA culture – is in her moment. Her comments in a lengthy 21 July ESPN profile stating her opposition to transgender athletes has earned her hero status of the specious “Protect Our Girls” movement, even though you’d need a microscope to find any critical mass of transgender women participating in sports at any level.

Excuse me? Why does it have to be a critical mass? Why isn’t one enough to object to? We don’t nod cheerfully if just a few people cheat in sports or elsewhere, so why should women nod cheerfully if less than a critical mass of men take women’s places in sports?

If a burglar dropped in at Howard Bryant’s house and took only some of the silver, a few books and paintings and bottles of wine, would he shrug and move on with his day? And what does a purported “white animosity toward the WNBA culture” have to do with anything? Just say you hate mouthy women, Mr Bryant; it will save us all a lot of time.

Comments

4 responses to “Throwing some random mud”

  1. Sumi Avatar

    “You’d need a microscope to find any critical mass of transgender women participating in sports at any level.” They keep repeating this tired trope as though it were true. It’s not.

    And let’s not forget that it’s the “be kind” left, not the right, that started the trans culture war. We, and here I mean liberals generally, are engaged in a project to normalize transgender and “queerness.” It’s us invoking a wounded innocence and whining, “lil’ ol’ us weren’t doin’ nuthin.’” Pretending otherwise is dishonest, but then, dishonesty is at the heart of the project.

  2. Freemage Avatar

    When it comes to sports, more than even most other areas of life, ‘permitted cheating’ has a critical mass of one. If you let one case get through, two things happen:

    First, every person in that sport who comes in below the cheater has their position altered in the rankings. Do the newspapers care about the 41st placed swimmer over the 42nd? No, but I guarantee you that the 42nd placed swimmer feels that reduction intensely. And that’s before you even get into the properly ‘professional’ sports, where you are actually talking about salaries and such.

    Secondly, it invites more cheaters in. Look at the steroid mess in baseball. Once you had a small group of men ‘roiding it up to improve their performance, a larger group started doing the same just to stay competitive, all with the tagline, “Well, everyone’s doing it.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *