All entries by this author

Please Sir Can I Teach Nonsense?

Jun 18th, 2006 7:31 pm | By

So ‘faith schools’ want ‘exemption from new equality laws in order to carry on teaching that homosexuality is a sin’ do they. That’s interesting.

At the moment, many faith schools make children aware of different sexual practices, but underline that anything other than heterosexuality is a sin. In a submission to the unit, the CofE said that it would not wish to discriminate against pupils or parents on grounds of sexual orientation in the context of admissions or in disciplinary procedures. But it insisted that schools should be free to teach that homosexuality is at odds with the Bible.

Thus we see why the realm of education, if it is to be real education, has to be secular. It’s like … Read the rest



Gain and Loss

Jun 18th, 2006 7:00 pm | By

Jean Drèze notes an important fact that’s worth keeping in mind:

Sen is praised as a “feminist economist” but it is not very clear what “feminist” actually stands for (except for a general concern with gender issues) and why Sen qualifies. A notable exception is Martha Nussbaum’s bold assessment. Taking issue with the notion that freedom is always a desirable social goal, she points out that “gender justice cannot be successfully pursued without limiting male freedom”.

Fer sher. And that’s one reason there is so much Faisal Bodiesque blather about keeping families intact and dealing with problems within the community, cluttering up the place – because improvement of the lot of women (whether you call it justice, or freedom, or … Read the rest



Jean Drèze on Feminist Reading of Sen *

Jun 18th, 2006 | Filed by

Nussbaum points out that ‘gender justice cannot be successfully pursued without limiting male freedom.’… Read the rest



Pratap Bhanu Mehta on Book on Dalit Phobia *

Jun 18th, 2006 | Filed by

In our discourse on caste, Dalits’ marginality and exclusion does not get the attention it deserves.… Read the rest



Hussaini Begum Deported *

Jun 18th, 2006 | Filed by

She fled India after she was raped and forced into an arranged marriage.… Read the rest



Bunting Leaves Guardian for Demos *

Jun 18th, 2006 | Filed by

‘She is a serious, independent and provocative thinker,’ says chair of Demos trustees.… Read the rest



Does Marx Still Matter? *

Jun 18th, 2006 | Filed by

The Independent asks Hobsbawm and others.… Read the rest



Whose Life Is It?

Jun 18th, 2006 1:20 am | By

Go, Sunny.

…annoying cultural traditions have a distinct knack of clinging on through generations. It would be no exaggeration to say that thousands of young British Asian women are forced into marriage every year…I have seen well educated and well adjusted friends slowly become nervous wrecks as their parents pile on the pressure…last week the Home Office decided a specific law to ban forced marriages was not needed. To put it mildly, the decision was not only a travesty but an unbelievably stupid fudge…Yet once again Labour has fallen victim to an army of Asian apologetics who prefer this muddle and like to pretend that the practice is very rare. Complete rubbish.

Go on.

For example, Pragna Patel from

Read the rest


Sunny Hundal on Betrayal of Asian Women *

Jun 17th, 2006 | Filed by

‘We need a few high-profile cases of Asian parents being put in prison to make [forced marriage] a social stigma.’… Read the rest



Family Court and Secrecy *

Jun 17th, 2006 | Filed by

False convictions are a problem – but so are false acquittals.… Read the rest



Jackie Ashley Talks to Melanie Phillips *

Jun 17th, 2006 | Filed by

Very carefully.… Read the rest



Multiculturalism as Ethnic Division of Labor *

Jun 17th, 2006 | Filed by

‘Even multiculturalism’s defenders often have little clue of what it really is, or does.’… Read the rest



Only Certain Science Stories Get Media Coverage *

Jun 16th, 2006 | Filed by

Scares about mercury fillings get headlines; follow-up research suggesting they are safe is ignored. … Read the rest



MMR is Back *

Jun 16th, 2006 | Filed by

Newspaper scare stories rely on unpublished research, so informed debate is impossible.… Read the rest



CofE: Homosexuality is at Odds With the Bible *

Jun 16th, 2006 | Filed by

‘Faith’ schools demand exemption from equality laws in order to keep teaching that homosexuality is a sin. … Read the rest



US Depends on Imported Talent for Science *

Jun 16th, 2006 | Filed by

Might be a good idea to educate some homegrown scientists.… Read the rest



Reliability? Expertise? Whatever Next?

Jun 16th, 2006 2:14 am | By

Scott has a very apropos column this week. Well, apropos from my point of view anyway – and in a very real sense, is not my point of view the only one that matters? Of course it is. And from that point of view Scott’s column reads like a sly follow-up to his column last week, the one in which he interviewed some bore who co-wrote a book about truth. Some of the commenters on that column, as you may or may not remember, rolled up their sleeves and got to work casting doubt on the whole idea of truth by breaking out the capital letters and the incredulous modifiers (certain, absolute) and the fleering quotation marks (“truth,” … Read the rest



Charles Larmore on Jerrold Siegel on the Self *

Jun 15th, 2006 | Filed by

Not enough Montaigne, no GH Mead, no Habermas; but still a useful book.… Read the rest



Column on Gay Marriage Leads to Dismissal *

Jun 15th, 2006 | Filed by

‘This isn’t Brigham Young Seminary,’ says BYU alumnus.… Read the rest



Scott McLemee Ponders Wikipedia *

Jun 15th, 2006 | Filed by

Accuracy, reliability, accountability matter.… Read the rest