Okay then! There are very tall men, therefore it’s fine for men to compete against women in women’s sports. We can all go home now.
A few examples of widely accepted physical differences in sports. pic.twitter.com/tiVKT4SxKs
— ❤️ Jameela Jamil ❤️ She/Her ❤️ (@jameelajamil) May 2, 2021
Rachel Cooke at the Guardian talks to David Bell:
Bell, a distinguished psychiatrist and practising psychoanalyst, is the doctor who in 2018 wrote a controversial report about the activities of the gender identity development service (GIDS), a clinic at the Tavistock and Portman NHS foundation trust in north London, where he worked in adult services from 1995 until his retirement earlier this year.
That’s the one that Keira Bell sued.
… Read the rest(The Tavistock is to appeal; the case will be heard in June. David Bell will be what is technically called an intervenor in the appeal, which means he can give evidence.)
Bell’s report anticipated the concerns of the high court and he feels vindicated by its judgment. “It was
The administration of former President Donald Trump obstructed an investigation looking into why officials withheld about $20 billion in hurricane relief for Puerto Rico following the devastating aftermath of Hurricane Maria in 2017, one of the deadliest U.S. natural disasters in over 100 years, a new report says.
Or to put it another way, the Trump administration withheld about $20 billion in desperately needed hurricane relief for Puerto Rico and then obstructed an investigation into this brutal theft.
… Read the restThe Trump administration’s OMB also insisted on overhauls to Puerto Rico’s property management records, suspension of its minimum wage on federal contracts and other prerequisites to access relief funds, according to the report. Some HUD officials worried such
As Skeletor mentioned in Miscellany Room, Caitlyn Jenner got something right for a change.
I didn’t expect to get asked this on my Saturday morning coffee run, but I’m clear about where I stand. It’s an issue of fairness and we need to protect girls’ sports in our schools.https://t.co/YODLDQ3csP
— Caitlyn Jenner (@Caitlyn_Jenner) May 1, 2021
Guess who doesn’t approve.
They didn't stop you smashing your opponent's skull in the cage, Fox. Then you bragged about it. Well done for generating TERFs with that horrible tweet. The internet never forgets.
— Scattergrains (@scattergrains) May 1, 2021
Originally a comment by Your Name’s not Bruce? on What comfortable looks like.
And it isn’t resolved by transferring the problem to GC feminists, and attacking them as the enemy. They are the ones with the most understanding of the real problem, because we feel it ourselves. We live with it every day, and somehow manage without cutting off healthy parts, changing our name or our pronouns, or adopting the stereotypical image of the opposite sex.
It’s amazing how allegedly progressive people and organizations have bought into gender ideology, which is irredemably regressive and reactionary. Gender critical feminists are actually fighting the real war.
In the eyes of trans activists, GC feminists are the enemy, and for good reason. … Read the rest
Another crack in the dam.
The word "breasts" is not mentioned here. Nor "masectomy".
Major surgery is being promoted to young women all over the world as a route to liberation ("a freeing freeing experience") while medical, anatomical reality vanishes into euphemismhttps://t.co/G6mbbi28La— Susanna Rustin (@SusannaRustin) May 1, 2021
Exactly.
But this glossy Hollywood promotion of a "having your breasts removed could save your life" narrative (with children's lives referenced explicitly) is disturbing.
What I see (among other things) is capital looking for places to flow and finding human bodies =natural resources— Susanna Rustin (@SusannaRustin) May 1, 2021
Very damn disturbing indeed.
The thread is all the more encouraging when you see that Rustin is a leader writer … Read the rest
I didn’t know the Australian PM is an evangelical.
… Read the restScott Morrison has asked a national conference of Christian churches to help him help Australia, while revealing his belief that he and his wife, Jenny, have been called upon to do God’s work.
In video that has emerged of the prime minister speaking at the Australian Christian Churches conference on the Gold Coast last week, Morrison also revealed that he had sought a sign from God while on the 2019 election campaign trail, and that he had practised the evangelical tradition of the “laying-on of hands” while working in the role of prime minister.
He also describes the misuse of social media as the work of “the evil one”, in
On Any Questions yesterday, starting at 33:50 minutes, a caller named Arthur asked “What is a woman?”
Jackie Baillie, Labour, starts with “I’m supportive of the Gender Recognition Act,” then says she recognizes “there are women who will identify as being a women based on their sex”
Ok let’s pause there – that’s a “recognize” too many. Women don’t “identify as being women based on their sex.” They just are women. Women are women, based on their sex. Sticking the I-word in there adds nothing but confusion.
She continues “and there are trans people whooo you know may be born as a different gender who will identify as women and I think we should demedicalize the process and enable … Read the rest
How the headline looks on the BBC front page:
Whoever is in charge of that front page is sending a signal. Nicely done.… Read the rest
The BBC solemnly reports on “Elliot” Page’s conversation with Oprah Winfrey.
Elliot Page says having transition surgery has been a “life-saving” experience.
So what the BBC is doing here is promoting the idea that getting your healthy breasts cut off can be life-saving. That is, the BBC is encouraging girls and women to think it can be good to get your healthy breasts cut off. Why is the BBC doing that?
The Canadian-born actor, 34, said having top surgery had allowed him to “feel comfortable in my body for probably the first time”.
And why is the BBC calling it “top surgery”? Why is the BBC, a grown-up institution, using baby talk for amputation of healthy breasts? There’s no … Read the rest
Someone is shocked and hurt in Halifax.
“Shocked and hurt” is how Alicia Frederick says she felt when she learned about a new book purchased by Halifax Public Libraries.
Public libraries buy a lot of books. It’s not really a worthwhile project to try to monitor their purchases for what makes you, Random Person, shocked and hurt. Libraries don’t and can’t filter their acquisition process according to what might possibly make someone feel shocked and hurt.
… Read the restThe library currently owns two copies of the book by Abigail Shrier, called Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters. As of this writing, 21 people have it on hold. The book’s description on the library website says:
Unsuspecting parents are awakening
The headline, for a start.
‘It is life-saving’: Elliot Page reveals happiness at having had top surgery
That is, Elliot Page claims happiness at having had her healthy breasts cut off.
It has been widely noted that Page doesn’t appear the least bit happy in her interview with Oprah Winfrey.
“I want people to know that not only has it been life-changing for me, I do believe it is life-saving and it’s the case for so many people,” the actor told Oprah Winfrey on her new show for Apple TV+.
So more and more and more girls and women should get their healthy breasts cut off. It will make them so happy.
Unless of course it doesn’t, but hey, … Read the rest
Another day another dude doing a Zoom meeting for work without bothering to put pants on.
Joshua Wolf Shenk, author of the books “Lincoln’s Melancholy” and “Powers of Two,” has resigned from his positions as editor in chief of the Believer magazine and artistic and executive director of the Black Mountain Institute.
Because of the no pants.
… Read the restIn a farewell letter shared with the staff, Shenk said his resignation followed “a dumb, reckless choice to disregard appropriate setting and attire for a Zoom meeting. I crossed a line that I can’t walk back over. I sorely regret the harm to you — and, by extension, to the people we serve. I’m sorry.”
The incident occurred during a
Uh huh great, woman journalist skewers governor for signing a bill that would keep boys from playing on girls’ athletic teams.
West Virginia Gov. Jim Justice struggled to come up with a single example of a transgender athlete gaining an unfair advantage in sports while being grilled Friday by MSNBC’s Stephanie Ruhle over why he signed a bill targeting transgender athletes.
It’s not about “targeting” anyone, and the issue is boys who get a hefty advantage by moving over to the girls’ team.
… Read the rest“Can you name one example of a transgender child trying to gain an unfair competitive advantage at a school there in West Virginia?” Ruhle asked Justice.
“Well, Stephanie, I don’t have that experience exactly to myself
Lesson: don’t mess with Maya.
The answer is no. pic.twitter.com/0kh335VOTt
— Maya Forstater (@MForstater) April 30, 2021
That’s them told.… Read the rest
Medical advice from random podcasters is not one of our best inventions.
Hugely popular US podcast host Joe Rogan has backpedalled on his comments that young, healthy people could forgo the coronavirus vaccine.
“I’m not an anti-vax person,” Rogan said. “I believe they’re safe and encourage many people to take them.”
But Rogan did not walk back his suggestion that the young and healthy do not “need” vaccines, which drew backlash from White House officials.
Why call it “backlash”? What a stupid word to use. Rogan shouldn’t be making such reckless and destructive “suggestions,” and the government is entitled to say he’s wrong and must be ignored. This isn’t a game.
… Read the restAsked about Rogan’s comments, top US infectious disease expert
The placid sense of male entitlement just takes my breath away sometimes.
https://twitter.com/kazarnowicz/status/1388153071428046849… Read the restClassic. It’s women’s fault when men kill men!
Update:
Dan Arel tweeted
Um, TERFS are Nazi though.
Also LOL at people calling me a misogynist for believing that trans women are women.
TERFS get trans women killed. End of story.
Feminists don’t kill men who say they are men, but feminists somehow “get” such men killed. They must be witches!
In fact when you think about it, really think about it, all women are bitches. They all make men do things. Men are pure and perfect and guiltless, but women put their witchy magic on the pure perfect men and “get” bad things done by those men.
It’s scary scary stuff. Medical science needs to hurry up with those uterus … Read the rest
Male athlete says it’s “fundamentally unfair” to have athletic teams for girls or women.
A Canadian transgender athlete says it’s “reprehensible” that some U.S. states are trying to ban trans women and girls from playing for female sports teams.
Of course he’s a male himself, and competing against women gives him a huge advantage, so that could be why he’s saying that. Just a thought.
“What they’re really doing is fighting for what one might call the non-existent rights of [non-transgender] women and girls, while treating trans girls and trans women as not real girls or women,” said Veronica Ivy, a two-time track cycling world champion.
Yes it’s our old pal Rhys McKinnon, talking about “the non-existent rights” of … Read the rest
The old “right to have access to a woman’s genitals” take.
https://twitter.com/AdamWagner1/status/1387733202983440384How sensitive and humane to frame women as a resource men have a right to use.
https://twitter.com/wwwritingclub/status/1387861486236848135 https://twitter.com/tkingdot/status/1387866307941609475 https://twitter.com/sarahditum/status/1387780570328014854In other news, one of the 87 Duggar kids from the “87 and counting” tv show about religious fanatics trying to break world records on how many children one woman can push out – one of those kids has been arrested.… Read the rest
