Here is that Newsnight:
All entries by this author
“We evolve to truly claim gender markers as our own”
Oct 24th, 2015 11:03 am | By Ophelia BensonA friend pointed out this set of tips by Katie Dupere on how to be a good ally to trans people.
It’s irritating stuff, of course, but it very quickly goes from merely irritating to reversing everything we’ve learned about the hierarchical system that is “gender” over the past few decades.
For the merely irritating –
… Read the restFor those in socially disempowered positions, being able to define how you’re spoken about can be really powerful, Stryker says. But in addressing language that can be non-inclusive, it is important to move toward a goal of education — not alienation.
“It’s about creating a space so you can go deeper into the issue, rather than trying to police speech in a way
Guest post: Transcript of Newsnight interview with Germaine Greer
Oct 24th, 2015 10:25 am | By Ophelia Benson“Amateur” transcript by commenter eigensprocketUK.
Newsnight 23 October 2015
STUDIO INTRO: Kirsty Wark, presenter of BBC’s “Newsnight”.
KW: Dr Germaine Greer has always been outspoken, but never before has she been “no-platformed”. A petition has been launched asking Cardiff University to cancel a lecture she’s due to give next month entitled “Women and Power – the Lessons of the 20th Century” saying that her views – on something else, transgender people – are problematic.
KW: She believes that men who transition can not then be “women”. And Cardiff Student Union Women’s Officer has said that her views towards transgender women are misogynist. The university’s vice-chancellor has said that the university is committed to freedom of speech and … Read the rest
If men had babies
Oct 23rd, 2015 6:13 pm | By Ophelia Benson… Read the restWhen Helen Linehan found out in 2004 that there was something fatally wrong with the 11-week-old foetus she was carrying, she was advised to have an immediate termination, because doctors knew there was no chance that the baby would survive longer than an hour after birth.
The foetus had a condition known as acrania, which meant that its skull had not closed over the brain. Although it probably would have survived inside the womb, it would not have lived once it was born, and doctors were clear that termination was the only option. Accompanied by her husband, Graham – writer of the television comedy series Father Ted, Black Books and The IT Crowd – she
Stop the silencing
Oct 23rd, 2015 11:17 am | By Ophelia BensonBut there’s a counter-petition.
… Read the restThere is a petition to Cardiff to cancel Germaine Greer’s talk. I find it abhorrent that I must make a counterpetition so a second wave feminist isn’t silenced by those who could just as easily not go to the lecture yet instead have decided to try and no platform her, to silence her. They’ve given no evidence in the petition either, just slurs.
This reactionary tactic of calling a woman a ‘transphobe’ is no different than calling someone a ‘commie’ in 1960’s America during the cold war. It’s a slur that contains no analysis, just an emotional response that is primarily used against women who talk about women’s biological realities, not gender identities.
Greer centers
Mixed company
Oct 23rd, 2015 11:03 am | By Ophelia BensonGod I hate finding myself agreeing with Brendan O’Neill…and not just for political reasons, but because he’s so transparently and irritatingly a Self-conscious Preening Contrarian. But it can’t be helped: for once Preening Contrarian has a point.
… Read the restIf you want to know how crazy, even Kafkaesque, this young millennium has become, consider this: yesterday it was reported that a person with a penis — Caitlyn Jenner — will be named Glamour magazine’s Woman of the Year, while over at Cardiff University a woman who has done more than most to secure the liberation of womankind — Germaine Greer — was denounced by a swarm of Stepford Students as ‘transphobic’, someone who should make all right-minded people feel ‘sick
This is not really a point for debate
Oct 23rd, 2015 10:13 am | By Ophelia BensonBut don’t worry – Huffington Post UK has a post by another Cardiff student who explains why it’s such a good idea to cancel Germaine Greer’s lecture.
So, notable second-wave feminist writer and scholar Germaine Greer is transphobic (more specifically transmisogynistic).
That’s the first sentence. It made me want very badly to stop reading. Why? That stupid “second-wave” shit. That label makes it sound as if Germaine Greer simply stopped thinking around 1975, and morphed into a statue that can be wheeled out to say 1975 things but nothing else.
Also, of course, the “transphobic (more specifically transmisogynistic)” part, which I have learned to be deeply suspicious of.
But maybe the student, Payton Quinn, goes on to make a case?… Read the rest
They urge Cardiff University to cancel this event
Oct 23rd, 2015 9:36 am | By Ophelia BensonAnother one.
A petition, by a student at Cardiff University, to Cardiff University, demanding that it cancel a scheduled lecture by Germaine Greer.
The lecture is scheduled for November 18 and according to the CU blog it’s fully booked.
… Read the restAcademic and broadcaster Professor Germaine Greer will deliver this year’s Hadyn Ellis Distinguished Lecture on Wednesday 18 November 2015.
Professor Greer is widely considered one of the most influential commentators on 21st century life. She has made her presence felt on everything from Newsnight Review to Celebrity Big Brother. A former professor of English at Warwick University, Professor Greer became a household name when she published The Female Eunuch, attracting praise and criticism in more or less equal measure. She
It seems to be only defending pornography that brings them out
Oct 22nd, 2015 4:43 pm | By Ophelia BensonMichael Moorcock talked to Andrea Dworkin for the New Statesman in 1995.
… Read the restMichael Moorcock: After “Right-Wing Women” and “Ice and Fire” you wrote “Intercourse“. Another book which helped me clarify confusions about my own sexual relationships. You argue that attitudes to conventional sexual intercourse enshrine and perpetuate sexual inequality. Several reviewers accused you of saying that all intercourse was rape. I haven’t found a hint of that anywhere in the book. Is that what you are saying?
Andrea Dworkin: No, I wasn’t saying that and I didn’t say that, then or ever. There is a long section in Right-Wing Women on intercourse in marriage. My point was that as long as the law allows statutory exemption for a
Spotlight on Saudi Arabia
Oct 22nd, 2015 12:03 pm | By Ophelia BensonAdam Coogle, a researcher for Human Rights Watch, reminds us of some facts about Saudi Arabia.
Saudi Arabia’s dismal human rights record is getting media scrutiny, thanks in part to news that Saudi authorities plan to lash 74-year-old Karl Andree, a British cancer survivor, 350 times for possessing homemade alcohol. Flogging in the kingdom entails a series of strikes with a wooden cane, with blows distributed across the back and legs, normally not breaking the skin but leaving bruises.
In other words Saudi Arabia plans to commit a heinous crime in order to punish a 74-year-old cancer survivor for possessing some alcohol. Saudi Arabia is the criminal here, and by a wide margin. Hitting people with sticks is a … Read the rest
Guest post: True but irrelevant, or relevant but false
Oct 22nd, 2015 10:35 am | By Ophelia BensonGuest post by Bjarte Foshaug.
Hardly anything has greater potential for introducing absurdities into an argument than using words in a different meaning than your opponent while continuing to act as if you were both still talking about the same thing. Now, obviously words don’t mean anything in themselves, but get their meanings from us. If someone wants to apply the word “fish” to what most people call “bird”, and vice versa, they are free to do so. But then it’s either disingenuous, or stupid, or both, to go on talking as if everyone else were using the words in the same way. It’s as if we were having a conversation about clubs for hitting baseballs (let’s call them … Read the rest
A lot of anger at feminists
Oct 21st, 2015 5:33 pm | By Ophelia BensonJustin Trudeau says he’s a feminist, and proud to be one.
In an interview, co-sponsored by the Toronto Star, which aired on Monday night before the election (Oct. 18), Trudeau was asked by journalist Francine Pelletier if he would describe himself as a feminist.
“There seems to be a lot of anger,” Pelletier asked, “not just at women, but at feminism and feminists. Would you describe yourself as a feminist?”
“Yes. Yes, I am a feminist,” said Trudeau. “I’m proud to be a feminist.”
And not only that…
… Read the restTrudeau added that the public should pay more attention to developments in popular culture like Gamergate—a long-running controversy about sexism and violence toward women in video game culture.
“The things
So self-contentedly, exclusively male
Oct 21st, 2015 4:38 pm | By Ophelia BensonIn 1987, Ursula K. LeGuin sent a letter to an editor at Harcourt Brace Jovanovich who had asked her to blurb a new anthology of science fiction stories.
… Read the restJohn Radziewicz
Senior Editor
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
111 5th Ave
New York NY 10003Dear Mr Radziewicz,
I can imagine myself blurbing a book in which Brian Aldiss, predictably, sneers at my work, because then I could preen myself on my magnanimity. But I cannot imagine myself blurbing a book, the first of the series, which not only contains no writing by women, but the tone of which is so self-contentedly, exclusively male, like a club, or a locker room. That would not be magnanimity, but foolishness. Gentlemen, I just don’t belong
The smallest minority
Oct 21st, 2015 4:03 pm | By Ophelia BensonThis is very funny but also painfully true:
SIX WORDS TO REMOVE FROM YOUR VOCABULARY TO BE A BETTER ALLY TO ME by Wayne Gladstone.
… Read the restSure, you’re a good person. Each day you learn a little more about the rest of humanity, and just by clicking this link you’ve already shown your interest in being a better ally. But while you’ve living a good life, checking your privilege and learning about people of different races, religions, social orientations and identities, there’s an ally opportunity you might have overlooked. The smallest minority. Me. And while I may be a minority of one, I must remind you that my opinion of you is not based on a measured consideration of your cumulative
Guest post: It’s more than the messages you hear
Oct 21st, 2015 11:52 am | By Ophelia BensonOriginally a comment by iknlast on Without having to go back.
It’s more than the media. It’s more than the messages you hear. The messages we get are all around us, often unnoticed in any real way, subtle.
My father refusing to teach me how to start the lawnmower. His paying for my brother’s college on terms that were much more generous than mine.
Being kept in the dining room on Christmas with the women while the men went into the living room and talked about interesting things. Being the last one served. Being asked to make the coffee at the meeting.
Many of the messages aren’t “girls wear nail polish” “girls wear high heels”. They are subtle; the … Read the rest
Change the venue
Oct 21st, 2015 11:27 am | By Ophelia BensonThe death toll from last month’s haj stampede has topped 2,000, according to tallies given by foreign officials, making it the deadliest disaster in the pilgrimage’s history by far.
Saudi Arabia has yet to provide an updated death toll after saying 769 people died in the tragedy near Mecca, home of Islam’s holiest sites. But figures given by more than 30 governments around the world show that at least 2,097 foreign pilgrims have died.
That’s so horrific. It wasn’t an earthquake or a flood or a mudslide, it was just way too many people in one place, trying to carry out a “religious obligation” that dates from a time when Islam was a local religion and … Read the rest
If gender is social rather than natural
Oct 20th, 2015 12:21 pm | By Ophelia Benson… Read the restIf gender is social rather than natural, change and variability are always possible. Hence continuities also require a social explanation. One important continuity is the hierarchical relationship between women and men, which has persisted despite many changes in the meaning of femininity and masculinity and in the social activities of women and men. While male dominance can and does change in form and degree, it seems that gender hierarchy can coexist with a wide variety of beliefs about gender and with different divisions of labour between women and men. Gender thus denotes a hierarchical relationship between women and men, not merely differences between them. If gender is understood to be social, this hierarchical relationship needs to be explained as a
The woman whose life he took is forgotten
Oct 20th, 2015 11:38 am | By Ophelia BensonRemember when the interim director of the Berkeley Astronomy department said: ““Of course, this is hardest for Geoff in this moment”?
Now it’s Oscar Pistorius who is “in need of healing.”
… Read the rest[A] justice system serves society with a split purpose. There’s punishment of the perpetrator and an element of rehabilitation (which has been vigorously stressed in this case – the terms of his house arrest include community service). And there’s also the strong social message that the justice system serves: through its sentencing, it makes a comment on the seriousness of the crime and how profoundly it will be perceived. This is the sticking point.
…
Judge Thokozile Masipa had to deal with the facts in front of her,
Total aesthetic hegemony
Oct 20th, 2015 10:33 am | By Ophelia BensonSo now North America is wholly ruled by Absurdly Gorgeous Men.
I feel as if I should be indignant about this, because what does Absurdly Gorgeous have to do with governing or administration? Nothing. (Diplomacy though? Different story? In which case maybe not nothing at all to do with governing? Persuasion is a necessary skill in governing, and charisma is part of persuasion. We ugly people are not useful in that way, fairness or no fairness.)
Maybe I’ll be indignant about it next week or sometime, but right now I’m just amused.
Hottie McHotterson 1, 2, 3.… Read the rest
