May 4th, 2017 8:00 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Golly, I agree with George Will about something. He says the state of Trump’s mind is so parlous that it amounts to a disability. I think that’s right.
It is urgent for Americans to think and speak clearly about President Trump’s inability to do either. This seems to be not a mere disinclination but a disability. It is not merely the result of intellectual sloth but of an untrained mind bereft of information and married to stratospheric self-confidence.
I’ve been doing that all along. In that area my conscience is clear.
What is most alarming (and mortifying to the University of Pennsylvania, from which he graduated) is not that Trump has entered his eighth decade unscathed by even elementary
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
2 comments
Tags: Trump
May 3rd, 2017 4:36 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
That bit of Tuvel’s paper I reserved to take issue with later:
Generally, we treat people wrongly when we block them from assuming the personal identity they wish to assume. For instance, if some one identifies so strongly with the Jewish community that she wishes to become a Jew, it is wrong to block her from taking conversion classes to do so. This example reveals there are at least two components to a successful identity transformation: (1) how a person self-identifies, and (2) whether a given society is willing to recognize an individual’s felt sense of identity by granting her membership in the desired group. For instance, if the rabbi thinks you are not seriously committed to Judaism, she can
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
13 comments
Tags: Hypatia, Rebecca Tuvel
May 3rd, 2017 3:44 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Justin Weinberg wrote a piece at Daily Nous about the monstering of Rebecca Tuvel.
In the paper, Professor Tuvel takes up the question of whether the considerations that support accepting transgender individuals’ decisions to change sexes, which she endorses, provide support for accepting transracial individuals’ decisions to change races. She defends an affirmative answer to that question.
The result has been an eruption of complaints from a number of philosophers and other academics, expressed mainly on Facebook and Twitter. Among the complaints is the charge that the paper is anti-transgender.
That charge may come as a surprise to some readers, as it comes through quite clearly in her paper that Professor Tuvel supports accepting transgender individuals’ decisions to change
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
9 comments
Tags: Hypatia, Rebecca Tuvel
May 3rd, 2017 12:10 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Trump’s clueless stupidity strikes again:
U.S. President Donald Trump said he would meet with Kim Jong Un amid heightened tensions over North Korea’s nuclear weapons program if the circumstances were right.
“If it would be appropriate for me to meet with him, I would absolutely, I would be honored to do it,” Trump said Monday in an Oval Office interview with Bloomberg News. “If it’s under the, again, under the right circumstances. But I would do that.”
He’d be “honored” to do it. He is such a fucking fool.
McCain is not impressed:
Speaking to Joe Scarborough and Mika Brzezinski on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” on Tuesday, McCain said that Trump’s latest attempts to side with leaders like Kim
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
15 comments
Tags: Trump
May 3rd, 2017 4:37 am |
By Ophelia Benson
I’m told that Zoé Samudzi perpetrated a Twitter storm on Friday, and I gather that may be what set off the flamers who quickly got Hypatia to agree to throw Rebecca Tuvel under the bus. Samudzi tweets a lot, so I haven’t found the storm yet, but I found a more recent squall, and it’s nasty enough for any taste. She’s responding to Jesse Singal’s article yesterday.
https://twitter.com/ztsamudzi/status/859122708633665536
The piece is about Tuvel, specifically the attack on Tuvel and the retraction of her article along with a public attack by the editors. It doesn’t “give her a platform”; it reports on her abrupt deprivation of a platform. It’s not obliged to give other academics a “platform”; it’s an article, … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
24 comments
Tags: Hypatia, Rebecca Tuvel
May 2nd, 2017 5:28 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Jesse Singal has written a blast against the public trashing of Rebecca Tuvel’s article.
In late March, Hypatia, a feminist-philosophy journal, published an article titled “In Defense of Transracialism” by Rebecca Tuvel, an assistant professor of philosophy at Rhodes College in Memphis, as part of its spring 2017 issue. The point of the article, as the title suggests, is to toy around with the question of what it would mean if some people really were — as Rachel Dolezal claimed — “transracial,” meaning they identified as a race that didn’t line up with how society viewed them in light of their ancestry.
Tuvel structures her argument more or less as follows: (1) We accept the following premises
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
23 comments
Tags: Hypatia, Rebecca Tuvel
May 2nd, 2017 4:25 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Speaking of Andrew Jackson and slavery and the Civil War…here’s some background.
Jackson’s presidency coincided with the formation of state and national antislavery societies, the publication of William Lloyd Garrison’s Liberator , and the expansion of abolitionist efforts to awaken the nation’s conscience. Although abolitionists focused primarily on nonpolitical tactics, their activities inevitably intruded into politics. During the last two years of the Jackson administration, therefore, the slavery issue was reintroduced to American politics for the first time since the fiery Missouri debates of 1819–1821.
In the summer of 1835, shortly after the Democratic convention adjourned, antislavery forces organized a campaign to distribute propaganda tracts through the mails to the South. The southern response was predictable. Southern state legislatures
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
8 comments
May 2nd, 2017 3:59 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
The Feds are prosecuting a woman for laughing during Jeff Sessions’s confirmation hearing.
During Jeff Sessions’ confirmation hearings, Senator Richard Selby claimed that the North Carolina senator’s history of “treating all Americans equally under the law is clear and well-documented.” At that, activist and CodePink member Desiree Fairooz laughed, since Sessions is actually best known for being deemed too racist for a federal judgeship in the 1980s. As the Huffington Post reports, a rookie cop with no appreciation for irony arrested Fairooz, and prosecutors are charging the 61-year-old with attempting to “impede, disrupt, and disturb the orderly conduct” of the hearings.
Who is the prosecutors’ boss? Why, Jeff Sessions.
A lawyer representing Fairooz at trial noted that other
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
10 comments
May 2nd, 2017 12:03 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
So Ivanka Trump has at least once grokked the full horror of her horrible father, if the Times is accurate.
It was last October.
Inside Trump Tower, the candidate was preparing for a debate when an aide rushed in with news that The Washington Post was about to publish an article saying that Mr. Trump had bragged about grabbing women’s private parts. As Ivanka Trump joined the others waiting to see a video of the episode, her father insisted that the description of his comments did not sound like him.
When the recording finally showed he was wrong, Mr. Trump’s reaction was grudging: He agreed to say he was sorry if anyone was offended. Advisers warned that would not
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
10 comments
May 2nd, 2017 10:47 am |
By Ophelia Benson
Originally a comment by Salalia on Leiter on Thought Crimes Watch.
It seems to me that this dispute can’t be understood without the background: Transgender issues have brought about something of a schism within academic feminism; the side that favors more extensively accommodating transgender politics within academic feminism has clearly “won” and has mostly succeeded in ostracizing and delegitimizing their (academic) opponents.
Tuvel and her critics are all on the same “side” on issues of gender (as far as I know neither side in the Hypatia dispute actually opposes transgenderism-within-feminism ideology). But her ideas (extrapolating “trans” concepts from gender to race) threatens to split the academic antiracism movement in the same way that transgender issues split feminism, except worse … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
5 comments
May 2nd, 2017 10:21 am |
By Ophelia Benson
So now Trump is saying there should be a government shutdown. That’s new. The Republicans have deliberately caused them in the recent past, but I don’t think they have called for them ahead of time, as if they’re an inherent good.
President Trump on Tuesday called for a government shutdown later this year and suggested the Senate might need to prohibit future filibusters, dramatic declarations from a new commander in chief whose frustration is snowballing as Congress continues to block key parts of his agenda.
“Our country needs a good ‘shutdown’ in September to fix mess!” Trump wrote in a series of tweets Tuesday morning.
Or a tsunami! Or an earthquake! Or a direct hit from an ICBM!
That’s … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
3 comments
Tags: President Reckless Lunatic, Trump
May 1st, 2017 5:52 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Trump has stopped saying “Obama likes me!” He’s stopped saying he likes Obama. Now he says Obama was “very nice to me with words” but since then they have “no relationship.” Did he think they were going to be buddies? I suppose they could have played golf, but I’m pretty sure Obama knows more congenial people even for that.
Meanwhile he’s still saying Obama spied on him, and when John Dickerson tries to get him to explain what he means, first Trump repeatedly says “You can take it the way you want, you can take it any way you want,” as if it were all a matter of “taking” things one way or another, as opposed to a matter of … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
5 comments
Tags: Trump
May 1st, 2017 5:27 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Brian Leiter has two posts on the monstering of Rebecca Tuvel. The first is nicely titled Thought crimes watch: comparing trans-racialism to transgenderism verboten!
A majority of the editorial board of an allegedly scholarly journal apologizes for publishing an article (which presumably went through whatever passes for peer review there) called “In Defense of Transracialism,” by Rebecca Tuvel, an Assistant Professor of Philosophy at Rhodes College. Here’s the abstract for the thought crime article:
Former NAACP chapter head Rachel Dolezal’s attempted transition from the white to the black race occasioned heated controversy. Her story gained notoriety at the same time that Caitlyn (formerly Bruce) Jenner graced the cover of Vanity Fair, signaling a growing acceptance of transgender identity. Yet criticisms
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
17 comments
Tags: Hypatia
May 1st, 2017 4:28 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
The open letter to Hypatia that their groveling apology was a response to is pretty horrifying if it really comes from academics.
As scholars who have long viewed Hypatia: A Journal of Feminist Philosophy as a valuable resource for our communities, we write to request the retraction of a recent article, entitled, “In Defense of Transracialism.” Its continued availability causes further harm, as does an initial post by the journal admitting only that the article “sparks dialogue.”
In what circumstances is it normal to request an academic journal to retract an article? I assume it would have to be for reasons of gross malpractice or dishonesty – shameful mistakes or shameful lies. The “scholars” who wrote the letter have other … Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
13 comments
Tags: Hypatia
May 1st, 2017 1:12 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Hypatia’s statement on Facebook:
To our friends and colleagues in feminist philosophy,
We, the members of Hypatia’s Board of Associate Editors, extend our profound apology to our friends and colleagues in feminist philosophy, especially transfeminists, queer feminists, and feminists of color, for the harms that the publication of the article on transracialism has caused. The sources of those harms are multiple, and include: descriptions of trans lives that perpetuate harmful assumptions and (not coincidentally) ignore important scholarship by trans philosophers; the practice of deadnaming, in which a trans person’s name is accompanied by a reference to the name they were assigned at birth; the use of methodologies which take up important social and political phenomena in dehistoricized and decontextualized
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
10 comments
Tags: Hypatia
May 1st, 2017 1:04 pm |
By Ophelia Benson
Another one of these – a public grovel and shunning over someone – a woman, naturally – saying Wrong Things about transracialism and transgenderism. The CHE reports:
The feminist philosophy journal Hypatia has apologized for publishing an article comparing transracialism with transgenderism.
In a post on the journal’s Facebook page on Monday, “a majority of the Hypatia’s Board of Associated Editors” signed a lengthy and “profound apology” in which they said that “clearly, the article should not have been published.”
The article, ”In Defense of Transracialism,” by Rebecca Tuvel, an assistant professor of philosophy at Rhodes College, drew a significant backlash following its publication, in late March. The article discusses public perceptions of racial and gender transitions by comparing
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
6 comments
Tags: Hypatia
May 1st, 2017 11:07 am |
By Ophelia Benson
David Graham at the Atlantic on Trump’s history lesson:
“I said, ‘When was Andrew Jackson?’ It was 1828, that’s a long time ago, that was Andrew Jackson,” Trump said, a sign that the history to follow would be somewhat shaky. Reminiscing about a visit to Tennessee in March, Trump continued:
I mean had Andrew Jackson been a little later you wouldn’t have had the Civil War. He was a very tough person, but he had a big heart. He was really angry that he saw what was happening with regard to the Civil War, he said, “There’s no reason for this.” People don’t realize, you know, the Civil War, if you think about it, why? People don’t ask that
…
Read the rest
Posted in Notes and Comment Blog |
12 comments
Tags: President Ignoramus, Trump