Just stop

Oh honestly. Putting the substance aside for the moment, this sentimental slush has never been relentlessly deployed this way for any other subordinated group. No, trans people en masse don’t “deserve” love – nobody does. It’s not true and it’s extremely ick. It’s a dopy change of subject. Campaigning for equal rights is not the same thing as campaigning for love and cuddles and a teddy bear.

If you think about it for one second it becomes obvious – a campaign for human rights can’t afford to attach it to a demand for universal love, because universal love of huge populations is a demand that’s impossible to meet. If the human rights depend on love then they become unobtainable. Rights have nothing to do with love. They are independent of love. They have to be, because they have to apply across the board, without regard to how we feel about the niceness or otherwise of the people at issue. Prisoners have rights. Murderers have rights. Love is not the issue.

Comments

3 responses to “Just stop”

  1. guest Avatar

    I think when they write ‘deserve love’ they don’t mean that we’re supposed to love them but rather that they ‘deserve’ to be able to have loving relationships and families. As with everything else in the ‘trans’ movement, they’ve stolen the phrase and idea from the campaign for another marginalised group, gay people.

  2. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Hmmmm. I don’t think so. I don’t think it’s as thoughtful as that. I think it’s just the usual sentimental sludge that accompanies all pro-trans ideology. The rhetoric around this particular “activism” is strikingly sentimental and mawkish. I would love to know why that is.

    Your interpretation fits though, and I can believe that some people mean it that way.

  3. Athel Cornish-Bowden Avatar
    Athel Cornish-Bowden

    We need a proper debate in Parliament on them, and what they mean for our trans constituents.

    And what about your vastly more numerous constituents who are real women? Do they not count?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *