Two visibly Jewish men

From the Guardian four days ago on the Golders Green stabbings:

Prime minister Keir Starmer said he would visit Golders Green “as soon as possible” after today’s “appalling attack”.

He chaired a Cobra meeting after two people were stabbed in Golders Green, north-west London, in an incident that police are treating as a terrorism offence.

Starmer also said he would meet with criminal justice agencies on Thursday. Speaking to broadcasters, he said: “The Government is taking action in relation to security, cohesion, extremism, but of course it’s our responsibility to coordinate the immediate response here to this appalling attack, to ensure security is in place, to take other measures.”

Cohesion. Is cohesion even possible? Anywhere, ever? Are humans simply incapable of it? Are there always and everywhere differences that prompt and motivate and solidify the formation of tribes and thus rivalries?

The UK had a massive labor shortage after the war, and it recruited people from part of what had been The Empire. I wonder how much, if any, thought was given to the favored religion of that particular bit of The Empire, and how amenable it is to co-existing with other religions.

The Board of Deputies of British Jews and the Jewish Leadership Council have released a joint statement after the stabbing of two Jewish men in Golders Green on Wednesday morning.

The statement said: “We are sickened by yet another terrorist attack on our community, this time targeting two visibly Jewish men on the streets of London. This comes after weeks of arson attacks targeting Jewish premises, and just seven months after two Jews were murdered in Manchester on Yom Kippur. For many in our community, this feels relentless.

“Our thoughts are with the victims, and we pray for their swift recovery. We also thank the police, Shomrim, Hatzola and CST for their swift response.”

The groups then outlined that there were factors which led to this event taking place. “We cannot ignore the context: a wave of antisemitic hatred driven by extremists at home and abroad, including Islamist extremism that motivated the Heaton Park attack, and attempts by the Iranian regime to orchestrate violence against British Jews,” it said.

Is the whole point of religion the creation of ferocious hatred of people outside one’s favored religion? It so often looks that way.

Comments

8 responses to “Two visibly Jewish men”

  1. Harry Kendall Avatar
    Harry Kendall

    I see you are part of the conspiracy over the narrative here.

    All over the media,it is, “two Jewish men stabbed”.

    And yet the suspect has been charged with THREE counts of attempted murder. What?

    Nobody seems to care about OR EVEN WANT MENTIONED the unfortunate *Muslim* stabbed by the same perpetrator the same day. That would not fit the narrative. No COBRA meetings for that man or anyone like him. Stop talking about him!

    Oh.

    You didn’t. And neither did almost anyone else, as the government of the UK wonder out loud about banning protests against Israeli genocide.

    If you want to know who’s really in charge, all you need to know is who you’re not allowed to criticise. And watch who goes along with that control.

  2. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Hang on, I didn’t know about the unfortunate Muslim stabbed by the same man. I’m not part of the conspiracy if I just didn’t know.

  3. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Ok, I found a Guardian article that reports it; I’ll update the post.

  4. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Correction: I’ll do a new post.

  5. Lady Mondegreen Avatar
    Lady Mondegreen

    I see you are part of the conspiracy over the narrative here.

    There is no “conspiracy narrative” here. The attack on the Muslim victim was a personal dispute. The two Jewish men attacked were strangers, and identifiably Jewish.

    If you want to know who’s really in charge, all you need to know is who you’re not allowed to criticise. And watch who goes along with that control.

    Ah, yes, the Jews are in control. Where have we heard that before.

    And we’re “not allowed to criticize”. We can hold huge rallies, marches of up to 300,000 people, shout “Globalize the Intifada!” and “From the River to the Sea!”, be heavily biased against Israel, bully Jews, stab Jews, murder Jews, but…right, we are allowed to criticize Israel.

    By the way, anybody still accusing Israel of genocide is both an antisemite and an idiot. Hamas, supported by the majority of Gazans, starts a war by slaughtering civilians, loses approximately 3.6% of its population over the three year course of that war, and we’re told over and over that “genocide” is being committed — not by Hamas, which is in fact explicitly genocidal, but by Israel.

    Right.

    (And never mind that Hamas embeds themselves within the civilian population.)

    Clever as the IDF is, you’d think they could do “genocide” better than that.

  6. Miriam Ben-Shalom Avatar
    Miriam Ben-Shalom

    Thank you! It is good to read people who are taking on all the libel and bullshyte about Israel. Israel may not be perfect as it is a state –run by human beings. But it does not commit genocide nor other abuses; I am sick and tired of hearing the same old/same old time and time again. I often wonder what might happen were Israel to finally “have enough” and act on that. I hope not.

  7. Ophelia Benson Avatar

    Thank you back, Miriam!

  8. Mike Haubrich Avatar
    Mike Haubrich

    As with Lady Mondegreen and Miriam, the use of the word “Genocide” against Israel is offensive to me. I’m not saying there aren’t victims of rockets and bombs among the Gazans, but motivation here is important. Israel is not trying to destroy the Palestinian, FKA Bedouin, race or culture, they are trying to root out Hamas. I also don’t deny that there are factions of the Israeli government who consider the Palestinians as an inferior race to Israelis, but that is not the makeup of the Israeli government.

    As for religious violence overall, yes. Hector Avalos laid out a pretty good case for violence being a function of religion. Christians talk about a loving God who shows mercy to the converted, but Constantine used the sword rather freely and the practice continues the world over.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *